We kept walking, and we found a second marker, or what was left of one, half buried under a pile of leaves and dirt at the far end of the strip, and Robert dug it out with a small trowel, and he cleaned it off, and he held it up, and he said this was the original marker, and that it dated to 1987, the year the subdivision had been resurveyed, and that the stamp on the cap was still legible, and that the cap matched the records in the survey office. He set the original marker beside the moved one, and he measured the distance between them, and he wrote the numbers down in his notebook, and he said the boundary, drawn from the original marker, ran further back than the boundary Karen had been using, and that the strip of land I had thought was mine, the ground where the orchard had stood, fell on my side of the true line, not on the HOA's side of it. He said it carefully, the way a man says something he knows will matter in a courtroom, and he said he would put it in writing, and he would sign it, and he would stand behind it.
I asked him if the marker could have been moved by accident, by a truck or a mower or a storm, and he shook his head, and he said no, not like this, not this far, not with the ground packed down the way it was around the new position, as if someone had dug a hole and set the rod in it and tamped the dirt down around it on purpose. And then he told me something else, something he had not told me at the survey office, something he had been turning over in his mind on the drive to my house. He said Karen had come to him once, months ago, and she had asked him whether the boundary could be interpreted differently. Those were the words she had used, he said, interpreted differently, as if a boundary were a sentence in a letter and not a line in the ground. He said he had told her no, that a boundary was a boundary, and that the markers said what they said, and that she had not argued with him, but she had not looked happy either, and she had left his office without saying anything else. He said he had not thought much about it at the time, but now, standing in my back yard with a moved marker in one hand and an original marker from 1987 in the other, he was thinking about it a great deal.
Thomas and I walked Robert back to his truck, and Robert promised to send me his written report within a few days, and he told me to keep the plat maps and the deed somewhere safe, and to make copies of everything, and to let Sarah have a copy of his report the moment it arrived. I thanked him, and I meant it, and I watched him drive away, and then Thomas and I stood in the yard for a while, looking at the stumps, and neither of us said anything, because there was nothing to say that the stumps had not already said. The ground had been measured. The markers had been found. The boundary had been drawn in the wrong place, and someone had drawn it there on purpose, or had asked someone to draw it there, and now we knew.
The next day another letter came from the HOA. It was in my mailbox when I got home from work, in the same white envelope as the first one, with the same HOA letterhead, and the same signature at the bottom, Karen Whitfield's name in blue ink. I opened it at the kitchen table, and I read it twice, and then I read it a third time, because I wanted to be sure I was reading what I thought I was reading. The letter said I was to remove the structure from the easement within fourteen days, and that if I did not, the association would remove it for me and charge me for the cost, and that further fines would follow. I sat there with the letter in my hand, and I looked out the window at the back yard, at the nine stumps and the bare ground where the trees had been, and I thought about the word structure, and I thought about what a structure was, and I thought about the fact that a tree is not a structure, and that a stump is not a structure, and that there was nothing left in my yard that could be called a structure by any honest definition of the word. The trees were gone. Karen had them cut down. And now she was writing to tell me to remove the structure within fourteen days, as if the structure were still standing, as if she had not already sent the saws to take it down, as if the letter were written for a different yard in a different neighborhood where the trees were still alive.