The HOA Cut Down My Orchard — Then They Discovered Who Owned the Land Beneath It

Chapter 11

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The next morning I carried the gray file box into Sarah Mitchell's office, and I set it on the table between us, and I watched her open it and lift out the folders the way I had lifted them out the night before, only faster, with the practiced hands of someone who had done this a thousand times. She read the deed first, and then the plat maps, and then the HOA documents, and she made notes in a yellow legal pad in a handwriting so small I could not read it from across the table. She did not speak while she read. She turned pages, and she checked the letter against the documents, and she went back to the deed and read the easement paragraph again, and then she looked up at me, and she said the thing I had been hoping someone would say and also dreading someone would say, because once it was said out loud there would be no going back from it.

She said the HOA had a problem. She said the easement was real, and it was old, and it had been unused for about forty years, and that mattered, because an easement that has not been used for that long does not give the association the right to do whatever it wants on the land. She said the land under the orchard was not fully HOA-owned the way Karen claimed, and that the deed and the plat maps, read together, left the question of ownership open in a way that favored me more than it favored the board. And then she said something that made me sit up straighter in my chair. She said she had looked at the HOA's own records, the ones I had brought in, and she could not find any board minutes approving the tree-cutting. There was no record of a vote. There was no motion. There was no resolution. There was nothing in the papers to show that the board had ever met and decided, together, to send TreePro Landscaping to my yard on a Tuesday morning. A decision like that, she said, had to be made by the board, and it had to be written down, and if it was not written down, then as far as the law was concerned, it had not happened the way Karen said it had happened.

I asked her what that meant, and she told me plainly. It meant Karen might have acted alone. It meant the letter with section 7.3 might have been Karen's letter, not the board's letter. It meant the fine, the deadline, the saws, all of it might have been one person's decision dressed up to look like the decision of a whole association. She said she could not prove that yet, not from the papers I had brought in, but she said the absence of the minutes was the kind of absence that mattered, because boards that follow their own rules keep minutes, and boards that do not keep minutes usually have a reason for not keeping them.

Sarah told me what she was going to do, and she told me in the order she was going to do it, and I wrote it down in my notebook so I would not forget. First, she was going to send the HOA a preservation letter. The letter would demand that the association keep every record it had, every email, every text message, every note, every invoice, every photograph, every piece of paper that had anything to do with the trees, the easement, the letter, the fine, and the cutting. It would tell them not to delete anything and not to throw anything away, and it would put them on notice that if anything went missing after that letter arrived, a court would want to know why. Second, the letter would warn them that she would sue if she had to, and that she would sue for the value of the trees and for the damage to the land and for the way the whole thing had been done, and that she was not writing to ask for a favor. She was writing to tell them to stop, and to preserve what they had, and to understand that this was not going away because the trees were already gone.

News in the same category

The HOA Cut Down My Orchard — Then They Discovered Who Owned the Land Beneath It

45 Part