The HOA Cut Down My Orchard — Then They Discovered Who Owned the Land Beneath It

Chapter 9

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

I started with the deed, because the deed was the beginning. It was six pages, and the language was the kind of language that makes your eyes go tired if you read it too fast, all whereas and hereinafter and subject to the following. I read it slowly, with a pencil in my hand, and I underlined the parts that mattered. The lot lines. The description of the parcel. The reference to the subdivision plat. And then, on the third page, a paragraph I had never really noticed before, a paragraph about an easement. It said that a portion of the lot, described as Parcel 14-B, about thirty-seven hundredths of an acre, was subject to a utility and drainage easement recorded in nineteen sixty-two. I read the paragraph three times. Thirty-seven hundredths of an acre. That was the strip at the back of the yard, the ground where the orchard had stood. I had always thought of that ground as mine, because it was behind my fence and I mowed it and I planted on it and no one had ever told me otherwise. But the deed said something more careful than that. It said the land was burdened by an old easement, and it said the easement had been recorded in 1962, and it did not say the HOA owned the land outright. It said the easement was for utility and drainage purposes. It did not say the HOA could cut down trees on it whenever it wanted.

I went to the plat maps next, and I spread them out on the table, weighting the corners with coffee mugs so they would stay flat. The oldest map was from the original subdivision, and the lines on it were drawn in thin black ink, and the handwriting was the careful handwriting of a draftsman who had done this work before computers. I found Parcel 14-B on that map, and I traced the boundary with my finger, and I saw that the parcel was drawn as a long narrow strip running along the back of several lots, including mine, and that it was labeled with two words in small capital letters: DRAINAGE EASEMENT. There was a note in the margin, in the same careful hand, saying the easement was for a storm drain that had never been built, or had been built and then abandoned, I could not tell which from the note alone. But the shape of it was clear. It was not a building lot. It was not common area in the way Karen meant it. It was a strip of land set aside for a purpose, and the purpose had to do with water and pipes, not with whether a homeowner could plant a peach tree.

I kept reading. I went through the HOA documents page by page, and I looked for the section Karen had quoted in her letter, section 7.3, and I found it, and I read it in full, and what I found made my hands stop moving. Section 7.3 said the association could require the removal of trees that posed a hazard or that interfered with a recorded easement, but it said nothing about cutting down healthy trees on a Tuesday morning without notice, and it said nothing about a fine of four hundred and fifty dollars plus twenty-five dollars a day, and it said nothing about a deadline of six in the morning on a Monday. The letter Karen had sent on Friday had quoted the section number and then had gone on to say things the section did not say. I read the letter again, the one she had left in my mailbox, and I compared it line by line with the documents, and the gap between them was wide enough to walk through. The letter said remove the trees before six a.m. Monday. The trees had been cut down on Tuesday at about six forty-seven in the morning, after the deadline in the letter had already passed, and after no one had come to talk to me, and after no one had given me a chance to answer. The police had called it a civil dispute. The letter called it a violation. The documents called it something else entirely, or rather they did not call it anything at all, because the thing Karen had done was not in the documents.

News in the same category

The HOA Cut Down My Orchard — Then They Discovered Who Owned the Land Beneath It

45 Part