Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

Chapter 10

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Pillar two: the jacket. The camera in that store shows a man in a dark work jacket with a reflective stripe across the back — the same kind the warehouse issues, the same kind hanging in your closet. The state says: the jacket is his, the man is his size in a camera that lies about size, case closed. That pillar looks strong and it's made of sawdust. Those jackets exist by the hundreds in this county, and yours— He paused, and something in Isaiah's face changed, a memory surfacing and not yet named. "We'll come back to the jacket. Pillar three is the one that scares me, because it's the one that's really about you, Isaiah. No alibi. You told Reyes you were at your second job that night, cleaning offices at the distribution center, but the center can't produce your timecard, and a man who can't say where he was is a man a jury is free to put anywhere. Including in that store. With a gun."

It wasn't a real gun, they said the note— Isaiah started, and stopped, because armed robbery didn't require a real gun, only a clerk's belief, and they both knew it.

Four hundred and twelve dollars, Ruth said from the stove, very quietly. "That's the whole of it. Four hundred and twelve dollars, and they want to take my son's life and spend it in a cage." She wasn't crying now. Her voice had gone flat and hard, the voice she used with doctors who talked down to her. "What does the state say he wanted it for? A man with two jobs. What was he supposed to be buying?"

That's the soft spot in pillar three, Elijah said. "No motive that makes sense. No money found. No gun found. No car at the store that anybody can swear was his. The state has a clerk who couldn't see, a jacket that isn't one man's jacket, and a brother who can't prove where he was." He closed the file and rested both hands flat on it, and for a moment he looked every day of seventeen, and then the moment passed and he looked like the boy who had walked into Tolbert's courtroom. "So here's what we do. We find where you were. We pull the jacket apart. And we make Mr. Finch's crack into a split they can't paper over. That's the whole plan. It ain't fancy. It's just work."

Isaiah stared at the green light blinking at his ankle, then at his brother's hands on their father's briefcase.

You really believe all that, he said. It wasn't a question.

I believe what's true, Elijah said. "And you didn't do this. So somewhere out there, the truth's got paperwork. We're gonna go find it."

The distribution center sat out past the fairgrounds on a flat acre of cracked concrete, a quarter-mile of beige metal wall with a hundred dock doors in its side like the mouths of ovens, and at night, Isaiah said, it glowed from inside with a light the color of weak tea, and the cleaning crew went in through the personnel door on the north side, by the dumpsters, where the moths beat themselves against the security lamp in clouds.

Eight to two, Isaiah told him, the night before Elijah went. "That's the shift. Me and a lady named Pearl do the offices and the break rooms, and a man named DeShawn does the bathrooms and the locker rooms, and he's got seniority so mostly he does the vending machines, if you follow me. We clock in at the door. Or we did. Tanya changed the system in the spring."

Tanya Cole was the night operations supervisor, a broad, unhurried woman of about fifty with silver worked through her braids and a voice that carried the particular weariness of a person who has managed other people's nights for twenty years. She received Elijah in an office that smelled of lemon cleaner and copier toner, with a wall clock that ticked louder than clocks are supposed to tick, and she listened to his request with her chin on her fist, and when he had finished — he had rehearsed it in the truck, formal and complete, the dates, the hours, the legal basis, all of it — she sighed through her nose in a way that was not unkind.

Baby, I already told your brother, and I told that detective, and I'll tell you because you're polite about it, she said. "That week's paper timecards are gone. Gone gone. We had a pipe go in the storage room back in — oh, it was right after, too, which is a mercy and a curse. A pipe went and the whole room took two inches of water before maintenance found it. Cardboard boxes just melted. Half a year of records turned to soup. I put in the incident report myself."

Yes, ma'am, Elijah said. "Mr. Carrington told me about the flood. I was sorry to hear it."

Mm. She studied him. He was wearing the navy suit again — he'd decided the suit was his work clothes now, the way a uniform is work clothes — and the sleeves still ran long, and she took in the whole of him: the tie knotted with more care than skill, the notebook, the patience. "You the one stood up in court? Pearl saw it on her phone. She said the judge was laughing and then he wasn't."

Yes, ma'am.

Your brother's a good worker, she said, and something in her voice gentled. "Quiet. Does the bathrooms when DeShawn's back goes out and never puts it in the log for credit. I don't believe he robbed anybody. But believing ain't a timecard, and I can't give you what water ate. I'm sorry. I truly am."

I understand, ma'am. Can I ask you something else? When the system changed in the spring — the paper cards. What did they change from?

News in the same category

Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

45 Part