Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

Chapter 40

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Elijah, Isaiah called from the kitchen. "Mama says if you're communing with the ancestors, commune fast. Supper's at six and you're on peas."

Coming, Elijah said, and he set the Georgia Code on the desk, square with its edges, the way his father had set down everything he respected, and went to shell peas with his family in the last of the light.

The trial of Derek Voss took three days in the same courtroom, and Elijah attended every hour of it from the second row of the gallery, on the aisle, where he could see the bench and the witness stand and the back of the jury box all at once, the seat a person chooses when he has learned that a courtroom is a machine and wants to watch all its parts move. He wore the tailored suit. He did not wear it as armor anymore. That was the strange thing he noticed on the first morning, standing in the corridor with the light coming through the tall windows in dusty columns: the suit was just a suit now, well cut and dark and ordinary, and the boy inside it was just a young man watching a trial, and nobody in the building turned to look at him twice. A year ago that anonymity would have felt like erasure. Now it felt like a gift the world had given him, the right to be unremarkable, which was the very thing that had been stolen from his brother.

Isaiah sat beside him in a clean shirt with the sleeves buttoned at the wrist, his hands folded, his face doing the hard work of staying plain. He had not wanted to come. He had said so at the kitchen table, in the flat voice he used for decisions already made. Then he had gotten up the next morning, showered, shaved, and said, "If I don't look at it, it stays big. I'm done with it being big." Ruth had packed them sandwiches in wax paper as if they were going to a ballgame, because that was how she armed her sons for anything.

Derek Voss, in the flesh, was a disappointment to the imagination, the way the source of a family's worst year usually is. He was thirty-one, thin in the way of men who eat standing up, with a face that had been arranged around a permanent grievance and hair he kept pushing back with a handcuffed wrist's awkwardness whenever the deputies let him sit unshackled at the defense table. He was not a monster. He was a man who had needed money for a debt he would not name in any of his statements, who had known the QuickMart's closing routine because he had once stocked its shelves, who had worn a gray hoodie and carried a pistol he had bought off a cousin, and who had run, when the alarm surprised him, in the direction of the Carringtons' street, shedding the hoodie two blocks from where Isaiah had been walking home with his hands in his pockets and his whole visible life ahead of him. The case against him was not built of drama. It was built of the pawn ticket, dated the morning after the robbery, for a watch taken from the register clerk's wrist and pawned under Voss's own name because he had needed the money too fast to be careful. It was built of the gun, found in his sister's garage in a toolbox under a tarp. It was built of the marked bills from the bait bundle the QuickMart kept under the register, three of which had passed through Voss's hands into the till of a liquor store whose camera kept its recordings for ninety days. And it was built, on the second day, of Detective Paula Reyes.

She took the stand in a dark jacket with her badge put away, because she was not there as an ornament of the State but as a witness under oath, and Andrea Lindholm — who prosecuted the case herself, though she might have handed it down the hall, and everyone in the building understood why she did not — walked her through it without mercy or decoration.

Detective Reyes, who identified Isaiah Carrington as the man in the surveillance still?

I did, Reyes said. "I ran the photo array. I showed the clerk six photographs. I knew which one was our suspect, and the clerk knew that I knew, because I leaned — not in words. In the way I stood. In the way I waited. He picked the photograph I had already picked in my own mind, and I wrote it up as an identification, and it was not one. It was an echo."

Why are you telling this jury that, Detective? It does not help the State's case against Mr. Voss.

It helps the truth's case, Reyes said, and looked at the jury with the level gaze of a woman who had rehearsed nothing. "I have worn a badge for nineteen years. I have put men in prison who belonged there, and I will go on doing it. But I stopped a young man on a street because he matched a description that matched a hundred young men, and I let a bad identification carry weight it never earned, and an innocent man sat in a cell for eleven days while his seventeen-year-old brother read the Georgia Code in a public library to get him out. If I don't say that here, under oath, where it counts, then it didn't cost me anything, and it has to cost me something."

In the gallery, Isaiah's hands tightened once, and then, deliberately, like a man setting down a heavy box he had finally reached the right room with, they loosened.

News in the same category

Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

45 Part