Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

Chapter 31

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Elijah nodded back. Then he went out through the double doors into the Georgia afternoon, carrying his father's briefcase, toward Friday.

The courtroom filled the way a church fills for a funeral nobody had planned to attend — slowly at first, then all at once, until the bailiff was standing in the doorway with his hand raised, counting benches the way a man counts chairs at a wedding he knows will overflow.

Elijah Carrington arrived at eight-fifteen, forty-five minutes before the hearing was called, and the gallery was already a third full. He wore his father's navy suit. The sleeves still ran a little long. He had decided, after a long argument with himself in the bathroom mirror that morning, that he would not have them shortened, not yet, not for this. Some things you wear the way they were handed to you.

Ruth sat in the second row with her purse on her knees and both hands folded over the clasp, the way she held herself together in public. Harold Whitfield sat beside her in a gray suit that smelled faintly of cedar, his cane hooked over the bench in front of him, his notebook closed on his thigh. He had not opened it. He had told Elijah in the hallway, "Today isn't a day for notes, son. Today is a day for listening to other people say the things."

Isaiah came in through the side door with the deputy, and the whole room made a sound — not a gasp, exactly, more like the small collective intake of people who have read about a man in the newspaper and are now seeing the actual size of him. He was thinner than he had been in the spring. The ankle monitor made a soft, shameful lump under the cuff of his trousers. He walked to the defense table and stood behind his chair and did not sit until Elijah, without looking up from the folder he was pretending to arrange, said, "Sit down, Zay. You're making everybody nervous standing."

I am nervous, Isaiah said.

Then sit down nervous. It reads better.

Isaiah sat. His hands found each other on the table and held on. Elijah placed the three file folders in a row, squared them once, and then — because his own hands needed something true to do — he took them up and squared them again.

You don't need those today, Isaiah said quietly.

I know.

You brought them anyway.

I brought them anyway, Elijah said, "because the last time I walked into this room without everything I owned, a man laughed at me. Today everybody in this room is going to be carrying exactly what they brought. I want mine on the table."

At nine o'clock the clerk called the room to order, and Judge Raymond Tolbert came through the door behind the bench with his robe over his arm, which was not his custom, and hung it on the hook himself, which was not his custom either, and sat down and looked out over the courtroom for a long moment before he spoke.

He looked at the press in the back row — three reporters, one with a camera on a tripod by the door, a young woman from the Atlanta paper who had driven down that morning. He looked at the gallery. He looked at Andrea Lindholm at the prosecution table, standing already, her file held against her chest like a hymnal. He looked, last, at the defense table, and his eyes rested on Elijah for a beat longer than procedure required.

State versus Isaiah Darnell Carrington, the clerk read. "Hearing on the State's motion to dismiss."

Tolbert folded his hands. "Ms. Lindholm. The floor is yours. Take all of it you need."

Andrea Lindholm walked to the lectern the way she had walked to it a hundred times, but Elijah, who had studied her the way other boys studied point guards, saw the difference in her shoulders. She set her file down. She opened it. She took out a single sheet of paper and laid the rest aside, and the room understood before she said a word that the sheet was the whole of it.

May it please the court, she said. "The State moves to dismiss all charges against Isaiah Darnell Carrington, with prejudice, and I intend to state the grounds in full, on the record, because the record is where this case went wrong and the record is where it will be set right."

She did not look at her notes again.

Count one, armed robbery. Count two, possession of a firearm during the commission of a felony. Count three, aggravated assault. The State withdraws each count, and I will tell this court why, item by item, because Mr. Carrington is entitled to hear the architecture of his own exoneration built out loud.

Ruth made a sound then, small and involuntary, and Whitfield's hand moved, unhurried, and covered hers.

Item one, Lindholm said. "The identification. The State's case rested on an identification made by the QuickMart clerk on duty the night of March the ninth. That identification was conducted in a manner that does not survive scrutiny. The clerk was shown a single photograph before he was shown any array. That fact was not disclosed to the defense. It was not disclosed, I will say plainly, because it was not written down by the officer who conducted it, and it should have been. A suppressed identification is not a small error. It is the kind of error that builds a case on sand and calls the sand a foundation."

News in the same category

Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

45 Part