Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

Chapter 30

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Elijah looked at the briefcase between his feet. It was scuffed at the corners, the leather worn down to a lighter brown where his father's hands had carried it, and he had a sudden memory — not a courtroom memory, a kitchen one — of being nine years old and asking why a man who had never taken the bar exam kept a briefcase by the door, and his father saying: Because one day I might, and a man should be packed for the life he intends.

My father kept that briefcase by the door for twenty years, Elijah said. "He studied at the kitchen table after his shifts. He never got to sit the exam — the money, and then Isaiah, and then me, and then his heart. He died with the Georgia Code on his nightstand, Judge. I used to think that was a sad thing. A man packed for a trip he never took." He turned his hands over, looked at them. "Two years ago I started going to the library at night, after school, and I read everything he had underlined. He'd underlined the parts about evidence. About what the state has to prove, and how sure it has to be, and what a man's name is worth in the eyes of the law — he'd written in the margins. In pencil. Like he was arguing with the book, or studying for a cross-examination nobody was ever going to give him. When Isaiah got arrested, I wasn't starting from nothing, sir. I was starting from my father's margins. He taught me. He just did it before I knew I was being taught."

Tolbert was quiet a moment. Then he turned, in his chair, and looked at the photograph of the man in the field.

My father, he said, "was a farmer in Mitchell County. He sharecropped until he was forty and sharecroppers' sons will tell you what that arithmetic does to a man's back. He never entered a courthouse in his life — not once, not even when the land company cheated him in 'sixty-eight, because he said a courthouse was a place where men in suits decided what your word was worth, and he already knew what his word was worth, and he wasn't submitting it for review." A dry sound that might have been the beginning of a laugh, forty years late. "I have spent forty years on a bench being, as far as I can tell, an argument with that man. Every robe, every gavel — an argument that the courthouse could be a place where a man's word was worth exactly what it was worth at his own kitchen table." He looked back at Elijah. "On your first day in my courtroom, I laughed at you. Not out loud. Worse than out loud. I smiled the way a man smiles at a thing he has already decided is a joke, and I let the room see it, and the room took its cue from me, the way rooms do. I have thought about that smile every week since November. A boy walked into my court in his father's suit, carrying his father's briefcase, packed for the life he intended — and I was the thing my father warned me about. A man in a suit, deciding in advance what another man's word was worth."

Judge—

Let me finish, because Friday I'll say some of it in public, and I want to have said it once already, to the person it's owed to, before I say it to the cameras. Tolbert leaned forward, elbows on knees, a farmer's son's posture that no robe had ever quite trained out of him. "On Friday, this court is going to dismiss the case against your brother, on the state's motion, with the reasons stated on the record — all of them. And then I intend to do something I should have done the first day, before I knew a single fact. I am going to apologize. To your brother, for the four months. To your mother, for the grocery store. And to you, Mr. Carrington, for the smile. It will be on the record, where it belongs, in the places it counts. Whitfield told me you people have a saying about that." He almost smiled — the real one, this time, nothing sideways in it. "Things done in the light."

Yes, sir, Elijah said, and his voice was not entirely steady, and for once he did not train it to be. "They stay done."

Then we'll finish it in the light. Tolbert stood, and Elijah stood, and the judge put out his hand, and Elijah shook it, and the hand was dry and warm and ordinary, which seemed, somehow, to be the entire point. "One more thing. When this is over — and it will be over, Friday — you will go back to school, and you will take your examinations, and in due course, Mr. Carrington, you will sit the bar of this state, and I expect to be retired and in the gallery, and I expect to be insufferable about it. Do not make a liar of an old man twice."

Odom was waiting in the corridor. He fell in beside Elijah without a word, and they walked together the length of the public hallway, past the tall windows, past the courtroom doors — the same doors Elijah had come through in November with the sleeves over his hands and the whole room deciding what he was. The bailiff stopped at the doors and looked at the boy, and then, with the deliberation of a man placing something heavy exactly where it belongs, he nodded.

Not the nod you give a child. Not the nod you give a defendant, or a witness, or a problem in a suit. The nod you give a colleague, at the end of a long case, in a building where nods are a currency and everybody is careful with them.

News in the same category

Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

45 Part