Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

Chapter 6

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Finch's hands worked at each other. "He felt close."

I'm sure he did, Elijah said, and he said it gently, and the gentleness was worse for the State than any attack could have been, because the whole room could hear that the boy was not calling this man a liar. He was doing something more dangerous: agreeing with him, one fact at a time, in a direction. "A man with a gun feels like he's standing on your chest. But this court has to deal in feet and seconds, Mr. Finch, not feelings. You understand that."

I understand.

Now. The ninety seconds. During those ninety seconds, what were you looking at?

At him.

At his face?

At —  Finch stopped. His mouth stayed open a moment. "He had a gun."

Yes, sir.

I looked at the gun. I looked at the gun a lot. Doris — my wife — she said after, she said, 'Harold, you stared at that gun like it was going to spell something.'

A sound went through the gallery that was not quite a laugh. Elijah let it pass. He turned a page.

Mr. Finch, do you wear glasses?

Lindholm stood. "Objection, Your Honor. Relevance."

Tolbert had been watching the boy the way a man watches weather come across a field. The smirk was gone. In its place was something older and more dangerous to both sides: interest. "I'll allow it," he said. "The witness's ability to observe is always relevant, Ms. Lindholm. You know that. Overruled. Answer the question, Mr. Finch."

I wear glasses, yes, Finch said. "For distance."

For distance. Meaning you need them to see clearly across a room — across, say, twenty-two feet of store.

I can see without them. Things are just — softer.

Softer, Elijah repeated. "Were you wearing your glasses on the night of the twenty-sixth, Mr. Finch?"

The witness chair creaked. Finch looked at Lindholm, then at the judge, then at his own hands, and the room understood before he spoke that the answer mattered.

No, he said. "No, I wasn't."

Why not?

They were broken. It came out of him with the reluctance of a splinter being drawn. "I sat on them. Saturday morning, in my truck, I broke the frame clean at the hinge. Doris was going to take them to the place in Albany on Monday. That Sunday night I worked without them." He looked up, and there was appeal in it now, aimed at the whole room. "I didn't think it mattered. He was right there. A man doesn't need glasses to see a gun pointed at him from across a counter."

No, sir, Elijah said. "He doesn't. He needs them to see a face." He let that stand for exactly two seconds, no longer, because his father's notes had said a point left standing too long starts to look like cruelty, and cruelty loses rooms. "And you didn't mention the glasses to Detective Reyes, did you? Not that night, not in your statement the next morning, not at the lineup two days later."

I didn't think — nobody asked me.

Nobody asked you, Elijah said. "That's right. Nobody asked." He wrote something down, unhurried. "Mr. Finch, at the lineup — the six photographs, laid out on your counter. Detective Reyes told you the man might or might not be among them, and I believe she said it right. My question is different. Before that day, had you seen a photograph of my brother anywhere else? On the news? On your telephone? In the paper?"

No.

Had Detective Reyes, or anyone, described any of the men in those photographs to you before she laid them out?

No.

Then let me ask it plainly, sir, and take your time. Elijah's voice went quieter, and the courtroom leaned in the way it had leaned when the doors opened. "When you picked photograph number four — my brother's face — were you picking the man you saw on Sunday night? Or were you picking the man whose face looked most like the face you'd been carrying in your head for two days — a face you'd seen for ninety seconds, in a store with a light out, without your glasses, while you were looking at a gun?"

Objection. Lindholm was on her feet, and she was not a woman who objected for theater; her voice had a crack of real alarm in it. "Your Honor, the question calls for speculation. The witness can't testify to his own cognitive process."

Tolbert raised one hand, and the room stopped. He looked at Elijah for a long moment, over the glasses, and spoke with the care of a man handling something he has just realized is loaded.

The objection is sustained as to the form, he said. "But the witness may answer whether he is as certain today as he was on Tuesday." He turned to Finch. "Mr. Finch. Are you?"

Finch looked at Isaiah for a long time. The certainty that had carried him into the room was still there — but it had a crack in it now, and everyone could see the light through the crack, including Finch.

I believed it was him, Finch said at last. "I believed it then and I came in here believing it. But what that boy just said about the glasses — I never told anybody about the glasses, and now I can't stop thinking about the glasses." He shook his head slowly. "I saw a man. I know I saw a man. God help me, that's the most I can say the way I used to say it."

Nobody in the gallery moved. The court reporter’s hands had stopped, and then, remembering themselves, hurried to catch up.

News in the same category

Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

45 Part