Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

Chapter 41

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The jury was out for four hours. Elijah spent them on the courthouse steps with Isaiah, eating Ruth's sandwiches and watching the pigeons conduct their own litigation over the crumbs. When the clerk came to the door, the two brothers went back inside and stood, because Isaiah insisted on standing, and heard the foreman say guilty on every count, in a voice that shook only on the last one. The judge — a visiting judge from the neighboring circuit, a woman with silver hair and no patience for theater — sentenced Derek Voss to twelve years, and said, from the bench, that the sentence would have been identical had the wrong man never been charged, because the crime was the crime; and that the other matter, the eleven days, belonged to a record this court had already corrected and a conscience she trusted was already corrected with it.

In the corridor afterward, in the noise of deputies and reporters and the bailiff's radio, Paula Reyes came down the marble floor toward them with her hands empty and her chin up, a woman walking to an appointment she had made with herself a year before and kept postponing. She stopped in front of Isaiah.

Mr. Carrington, she said. "I'm not going to ask you for anything. I came to say that the identification procedures in my department are double-blind now. The officer who runs the array doesn't know which photograph is the suspect. That is policy, in writing, with my name on the recommendation. It changed because of your brother." She looked at Elijah, once, and something that was almost a smile crossed her face like weather. "Because he read the manual I hadn't."

Isaiah was quiet a moment. Then he put out his hand, and she took it, and he said, in the plain voice he had used at the kitchen table, "Then it wasn't for nothing. I forgive you, Detective. I mean that the way a thing has to be meant to work." He held her hand a second longer than a handshake requires. "You be careful with the next one."

I will, she said. "That's the whole of it now. I will."

Elijah watched her walk away down the corridor, past the tall windows, and thought about how justice, when it finally came, had not arrived as thunder. It had arrived as paperwork revised, as a sentence pronounced without flourish, as a handshake in a hallway. It was less than the movies promised and more than he had dared to ask for, and it was enough. It was, he was learning, almost always enough, if you let enough be a word with weight in it.

The legal-aid clinic occupied the ground floor of a brick building on Mulberry Street that had been a feed store, a church, and a dentist's office in its long life, and still smelled faintly of all three whenever it rained. Elijah had known the place before he knew the courthouse. As a small boy he had done his homework at the scarred table in the back room while his father, Marcus Carrington, took clients in the front, in the little office with the door that never fully closed, so that the sound of Marcus's voice — patient, unhurried, translating the law into the language of the person's actual life — had been the background music of Elijah's childhood, as ordinary and as formative as rain on a tin roof. Marcus had not been a famous lawyer. He had been a necessary one, which his son now understood to be the higher rank.

Elijah volunteered at the clinic three afternoons a week that last summer before the university, shelving intake forms, making coffee that the director, Ms. Odelia Grant, described as an argument for the existence of suffering, and sitting in on consultations when the clients agreed, which they almost always did, because there was something about the quiet boy with the notebook that made people feel the record of their trouble was being kept by careful hands.

Mrs. Dorothy Freeman came in on a Tuesday in July with her rent receipts in a plastic grocery bag and her landlord's notice folded into her Bible, where she had put it, she explained, "so it would have to behave itself." She was seventy-nine years old, a widow, a retired school cafeteria manager with hands that had fed four thousand children and a voice that still carried the cafeteria's cheerful command. The notice said she owed two months. Her bag said she had paid eleven years without a miss. Somewhere between her money orders and her landlord's new management company, the record of her life had been misfiled, and now a piece of paper was telling her to be out of her home of thirty years by the end of the month.

They said I can dispute it, Mrs. Freeman said, sitting very straight in the chair across from Elijah, her purse on her knees like a shield. "Baby, I don't know how to dispute. I know how to pay, and I paid. That's my whole side of the story and it fits in one sentence, and their side has stamps on it."

Then we'll make your sentence longer, Elijah said, and he opened the grocery bag the way his father had taught him to open any client's evidence — slowly, and in front of them, so they could watch their own life being treated as valuable. He laid the money order receipts out in rows on the desk, month by month, year by year, the carbon copies gone faint as old photographs, and he read each one aloud as he placed it, because he had learned in a courtroom in Camilla that a fact spoken aloud in the right room changes its weight in the world. Two receipts were missing their pair in the sequence — not unpaid, he saw at once, but misdated by the management company's own hand, the month written over, a seven turned into a nine by a clerk in a hurry three counties away. The money was there. It had always been there. It had simply been filed under the wrong month by someone who would never have to sleep in the house it paid for.

News in the same category

Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

45 Part