Elijah knew that drawer. He knew the watch in it, blue-faced and whole.
He pressed print, because the media room let you print stills for ten cents a page, and he fed his quarters in with hands that were not quite steady, and the machine hummed and delivered the frame into his hands still warm: a gray man, a gray store, a left hand reaching across a counter — and on the wrist, small and bright and unmistakable, the cracked star of a broken watch face, shining like a signature the man had never meant to leave.
He put the page in the briefcase, on top of everything, where it would be the first thing he saw every time he opened it.
Then he went home through the dark, past the courthouse, past the darkened windows of the QuickMart's whole lit and ordinary world, with the briefcase banging gently against his leg at every step, walking — though he did not know it yet, though he only knew the pen had scored a page and a clock had lied and a watch had flashed — directly toward the spring, and the trial, and the twelfth chair in a jury box where a stranger would one day look at that warm gray page and see what he saw.
The records came on a Tuesday, in a plain email with three attachments and no apology for the six weeks they had taken to arrive.
Elijah read the message standing up in Harold Whitfield's kitchen, because sitting down felt like something a person did when the news could wait. Whitfield's laptop sat open on the table beside a mug of coffee gone cold and a plate of toast neither of them had touched. Outside the window, the old man's yard was bright and ordinary — grass needing cutting, a bird feeder swinging empty, the street beyond it carrying Camilla through another morning as if nothing in the world were pending.
Open the second one, Whitfield said. "The first is a cover letter. Lawyers write cover letters so the facts have somewhere to hide."
Elijah clicked.
SOUTHEASTERN DISTRIBUTION CENTER — ELECTRONIC GATE ACCESS LOG — EMPLOYEE: CARRINGTON, ISAIAH J. — BADGE NO. 0417.
His eyes found the date first. The night of the robbery. Then the times, marching down the screen in the flat, unimpeachable typeface of a machine that had never met his brother and owed him nothing.
ENTRY — MAIN GATE — 22:47.
EXIT — MAIN GATE — 00:15.
Ten forty-seven in the evening. Twelve fifteen in the morning.
The robbery at the QuickMart on the other side of Camilla had happened at eleven twenty.
Elijah read the two lines again, and then a third time, the way he had once watched his father read a contract at the kitchen table of the old house — slowly, with one finger resting under each line, as if the words might try to move when he wasn't looking.
He was there, Elijah said.
He was there, Whitfield agreed.
He badged in at ten forty-seven and he didn't badge out until twelve fifteen. The QuickMart is twenty-six miles away.
Twenty-six miles by the route a sane man drives. Whitfield pulled a yellow legal pad toward him and uncapped a pen with his teeth. "Now we do the part the state will do, before the state does it. We try to make your brother guilty with these numbers, and we see if the numbers let us."
They worked it through the way Whitfield had taught him to work everything: out loud, on paper, with the other side's voice welcome in the room.
The distribution center sat off the highway north of town, behind a fence, behind a gate, behind a second fence. The QuickMart sat on the south side of Camilla, past the courthouse, past the water tower, on the road that ran toward the county line. Between the two lay twenty-six miles of two-lane road, four traffic lights, a railroad crossing, a school zone that never slept in the eyes of the county patrol, and one long dark stretch where the pine trees leaned over the asphalt like men listening at a door.
If he badged in at ten forty-seven, Elijah said, "and then somehow got straight back out without badging — over the fence, say — the earliest he could reach the QuickMart is—"
Drive it in your head at the speed of sin, Whitfield said. "Sixty miles an hour average, which no man alive averages on that road, with the lights and the crossing and the turns. Twenty-six miles at sixty is twenty-six minutes. That puts him at the store at eleven thirteen at the very earliest, with his engine still running and no time to park, no time to go in, no time to be the man on that video."
And the robbery took four minutes, by the register tape.
And then he has to come back. Another twenty-six minutes at a speed that would have put him in a ditch or on a patrolman's dash camera. Eleven forty-three at the soonest, back at a fence he has to climb in the dark, into a building full of supervisors, and then he has to stand around being an ordinary janitor until he badges out at twelve fifteen like a man with nothing on his conscience but mopping.
Whitfield set the pen down.
Now do it honestly, he said. "At the real speed of that road."