Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

Chapter 33

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

I have sat on this bench for thirty years, Tolbert said. "In that time I have made rulings I would defend to any court in this state, and I have made rulings that kept me awake in my own house, and I learned to live with both kinds, because a judge who cannot live with his record does not last thirty years. I am telling you this so that you understand the weight of what I am about to say, which is that there is no ruling in those thirty years that I am sorrier for than the way this case began in my courtroom."

The courtroom had gone the kind of quiet that has a texture.

When your brother walked into this room in March, I laughed at him. He said it flatly, into the record, while the court reporter typed and the camera by the door took it all. "He was seventeen years old. He was wearing his father's suit, which did not fit him, and carrying his father's briefcase, which had seen better decades, and he stood at that table and told me, respectfully and correctly, that he was here to represent you under the law of this state — and I laughed. I treated his presence as a joke at the exact moment when his presence was the only serious thing happening in my courtroom. I have thought about that laugh every week since. A judge's contempt is not a small thing, Mr. Carrington. It falls downhill. It tells everyone in the room what a man is worth before a single fact has been heard. I set the price on your brother, in public, at nothing. And then I watched, over the months that followed, as he proceeded to be the most prepared advocate to stand at that table in my thirty years on this bench."

Elijah felt his face go hot and kept it still by an act of will that cost him more than any argument he had ever made.

He read your case twice, Tolbert said. "He told me so the first day, and I have since learned that he understated it. He read the discovery the State gave him and then he read the discovery the State hadn't given him, which is to say he went and found it. He filed motions that lawyers with licenses and offices and secretaries do not file, because they have learned not to hope for what the law actually promises. He had not learned that yet. God willing, this profession will take its time teaching him."

A sound went through the gallery then that was almost laughter and almost something else, and Ruth pressed Whitfield's handkerchief to her mouth.

I want to be plain about what expungement means, because it is a word that sounds like paperwork and is not. It means that when Mr. Carrington applies for a job, or an apartment, or a license, and the box asks him whether he has ever been arrested, the law of this state will permit him to answer no — and it will be the truth, in the only register the law keeps. It means this spring will not follow him into every room he enters for the rest of his life, introducing itself before he can. The county cannot give him back the four months. The county can decline to take the next forty years as well, and by this order, it does.

So let the record show the following. Tolbert picked up the order and read it the way orders are read, each word given its full weight. "The charges against Isaiah Darnell Carrington, counts one through three, are dismissed with prejudice. They cannot be refiled. They are finished. Further, this court orders the expungement of the record of this arrest and prosecution from every index of this county and this state, and directs the clerk to issue certification of that expungement to the defendant and to every agency that received notice of these charges, at no cost to him. The bond posted by the Carrington family is exonerated and will be refunded in full. And the conditions of Mr. Carrington's release, including the monitoring device he is currently wearing, are terminated as of this moment."

He set the order down. "I apologize to you, Mr. Carrington, on behalf of Miller County, which arrested the wrong man and was slow to know it. And I apologize to you, Elijah Carrington, for myself, which is a smaller apology and a harder one. I laughed at a boy in his father's suit. The boy turned out to be the best argument this courtroom has heard in years — not for his brother's innocence, though he was that too. For the idea that the law belongs to whoever is willing to do the work of it."

He nodded once, sharply, like a man closing a door he should have closed months ago. "This court stands adjourned."

The gavel came down, and the room did what rooms do when a held breath is finally let go all at once — it became noise, chairs, voices, the Atlanta reporter already on her telephone in the aisle. Isaiah turned and put both arms around his brother and lifted him, briefly and entirely, off the floor, suit, briefcase, folders and all, and Elijah, seventeen years old and the most prepared advocate in Miller County, laughed into his brother's shoulder like a kid, because he was one.

The monitor came off in the clerk's office downstairs, which was not a ceremonial place — it smelled of toner and old paper and somebody's reheated lunch — and perhaps that was right, because freedom, when it finally arrives, usually arrives in a room like that, at a counter, from a woman named Delores who cuts the strap with office scissors and drops the black box into a bin and says, "There you go, baby," the way she'd say it to anyone, and means it exactly as much.

News in the same category

Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

45 Part