Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

Chapter 23

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

He sat down. The courtroom clock ticked, unhurried, through a silence with texture in it.

Tolbert turned. "Ms. Lindholm. The state's response."

Andrea Lindholm rose slowly. She had a folder in her hand and she did not open it, and in the gallery Harold Whitfield's hands tightened once on the head of his cane, because he had been a trial lawyer for forty years and he knew the posture of a prosecutor who has decided something on the stairs.

Your Honor, Lindholm said, "the state does not oppose the motion in full."

The sound that went through the gallery was not a gasp. It was smaller and larger than a gasp — the sound of forty people revising the world at once.

The state concedes that the photographic display conducted prior to the lineup was impermissibly suggestive, and that the witness's lineup identification cannot be defended under Biggers. The state withdraws any reliance on that identification. We do not concede — and we will address at the appropriate time — the admissibility of any in-court identification, nor the remaining evidence in this case, which the state continues to review. She paused, and when she continued, she was no longer reading anything, and the court reporter, to her credit, did not miss a word. "The state would rather lose an identification honestly than win a conviction with one it cannot stand behind. That is the whole of our response."

Detective Reyes, seated at the prosecution's table, did not move at all. Her face was a door with the light off behind it.

Tolbert removed his glasses. He looked at the motion, and at the prosecutor standing in a posture no one in Miller County could remember seeing, and at the seventeen-year-old at the defense table who had folded his hands to keep them still and was not entirely succeeding.

The court, he said, "has considered the motion, the witness's recorded statement, the disclosed procedures, and the argument of counsel — all of counsel." He let that sit. "The identification of Isaiah Carrington by Harold Finch, made at the lineup following the photographic displays described in the record, is suppressed. It will not be presented to any jury in this case, and no reference to it will be made in the presence of one. The state is directed to instruct its witnesses accordingly."

The gavel came down once, not hard.

Isaiah made a sound then, beside his brother — not a word, just breath leaving a man who had been rationing it — and Ruth Carrington, in the gallery, pressed her church-gloved hands over her mouth and wept without noise, the way she had learned to weep in public places so as not to embarrass her sons.

Tolbert should have called the next matter. Courtrooms run on the next matter the way rivers run on rain. Instead he sat a moment longer with his glasses in his hand, looking down the length of the bench at the boy in the suit that fit him now, who was writing the ruling into his notebook in his steady hand, word for word, as if it were a thing that might otherwise be taken back.

Mr. Carrington, the judge said at last, "this court owes you an apology it is not yet ready to make. Proceed."

The warrant for the pawn shop records was signed on a Tuesday morning, and Paula Reyes carried it across town herself, in the passenger seat of her unmarked car, inside a manila folder that had begun, over the last three weeks, to feel less like paperwork and more like an accusation she was making against her own reflection.

She had not slept well since the suppression hearing. She kept seeing Harold Finch's face in the witness chair, the way his hand had shaken when Elijah Carrington — seventeen years old, sleeves too long, voice too steady — walked him, question by patient question, to the moment in the interview room where she, Paula Reyes, had set a single photograph on the table before she ever showed him a lineup.

You might recognize this one, she had told him. She had said it kindly. That was the part she could not get past. She had said it kindly, the way you hand a frightened man a rope, and he had grabbed it, because frightened men grab whatever is put in front of them, and then she had written his certainty down in her report as though certainty were the same thing as truth.

The pawn shop sat on a frontage road off the highway, between a tire store and a check-cashing place with bars on the windows and a sign that buzzed. GOLD & GUNS & MORE, the sign said. Reyes parked under it and sat a moment with her hands on the wheel, breathing the way her training officer had taught her twenty years ago, back when she believed that doing the job right was mostly a matter of wanting to.

Inside, the shop smelled of metal polish, old carpet, and the faint chemical sweetness of the solvent they used to clean jewelry. A bell over the door announced her. The man behind the counter was sixty, maybe, with reading glasses on a cord and the careful stillness of a person who has decided, long ago, that his business runs better when he notices everything and remarks on nothing.

Detective Reyes, he said. "I wondered when it would be you."

You know why I'm here, Mr. Delgado.

News in the same category

Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

45 Part