Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

Chapter 18

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

And afterward, Lindholm said. "The police."

They were kind, Finch said, and seemed surprised by the word. "Detective Reyes, she sat with me. She said I was doing great. She showed me pictures on her phone first — no, not her phone. A folder. Photographs in a folder."

Lindholm's pencil stopped.

Tell me about the folder.

It was before the lineup. A day before, maybe two. Finch looked at his hands. "She had some photographs. Six, eight. She went through them slow. There was one she came back to. She didn't say anything about it, not really. She just — when we got to that one, she set it down a little separate, and she said, 'Take another look at this one, Harold. Sometimes the face comes back when you rest with it.'"

And at the lineup?

At the lineup I picked him. He nodded toward the wall, toward the whole machinery of it. "Number four. The tall one. I picked the one who looked most like."

The room went very still. Outside the door, the courthouse carried on — a cart, a laugh, somebody's shoes — but inside it, Lindholm heard the sentence land with the weight of a thing that cannot be unsaid, only answered for.

Most like, she repeated. "Not the man. The one who looked most like the man."

Finch's face worked. "I wanted it to be somebody," he said. "You have to understand. A man comes into your store and puts that fear in you, and then everybody is so kind, and they drive you home, and they tell you you're the only witness they've got, and you lie awake and the face in the dark is just — it's just a shape with a gun. And then they show you faces. And one of them is closer than the others. And everybody in the room breathes easier when you point. I pointed so the room could breathe. God forgive me, that's the truth of it. I pointed so we could all stop being scared of the shape."

Lindholm let the recorder run through a silence she did not fill.

Mr. Finch, she said at last, gently, "in the hearing, you said you'd know him anywhere."

I know, he said. "I said it because by then I'd seen his picture so many times he was the face. You show a man a photograph enough, it moves into the memory and sits down like it lives there. I can't tell anymore which parts I saw across my counter and which parts I saw across Detective Reyes's table. I have tried. At night I have tried. I can't."

She walked him out herself, past the flags and the metal detector, and thanked him for coming, and meant it. Then she stood a moment in the corridor with her hand flat against the cool wall, and went to find Paula Reyes.

The detective was in the second-floor workroom with her sleeves pushed up, annotating a report, and she looked up with the wary brightness of a woman who has decided in advance that this conversation is an insult.

Tell me about the photo folder, Lindholm said, and closed the door.

Reyes listened with her jaw set. "I showed him a photo array."

You showed him Isaiah Carrington's photograph twice before the array was assembled. Separately. With encouragement.

I showed him investigative leads. That's the job, Andrea. A clerk gets robbed at gunpoint, we develop a suspect, we test the witness against the suspect. You want me to investigate with my eyes closed?

I want you to investigate without building the answer into the witness. Lindholm kept her voice level with an effort that cost her. "He just told me, on a recording, that he picked the one who looked most like. He told me he can no longer separate your folder from his memory. Do you understand what that does to this case?"

What it does to this case, Reyes said, "is it makes a defense lawyer out of the prosecutor." She stood up. She was not a tall woman, but she had the compact force of a door closing. "You are taking the word of a terrified old man who changes his story with the weather over the word of the evidence. We have a partial plate that puts Carrington's car in that corridor that night. We have the jacket, Paula — " she caught herself, too late, on the name, "— we have the jacket the suspect wore, recovered in connection with Carrington's own workplace. We have a victim who identified him in a lawful lineup and again in open court. That is a case. That has always been a case."

The plate is three characters, Paula. Three characters match eleven thousand vehicles in this state. And the jacket—

The jacket is his.

The jacket was lent. Lindholm opened the folder she had brought and laid the gate log on the table between them, and watched the other woman read it the way a person reads a weather report for a town they love. "His badge entered the distribution center at ten forty-seven. It exited at twelve fifteen. The store is twenty-six miles away. I have done the drive-time arithmetic six ways, and there is no version of that night in which Isaiah Carrington is standing at Harold Finch's register at eleven twenty. None. So before I stand up in front of Judge Tolbert again, I need to know everything about how that identification was made. Everything. Including the parts that aren't in your report. Especially those."

News in the same category

Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

45 Part