Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

Chapter 5

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

sedan leave the lot "fast, without lights at first," and had caught a partial plate: the letters K and J, and a 7, she thought, though she wasn't certain of the order. A records check of vehicles matching the partial and the description, which produced, among a list of eleven, a 2016 dark blue Malibu registered to Isaiah Carrington. A jacket recovered — no, not recovered; observed, she corrected herself, in plain view in the back seat of that car during a consent search of its exterior: a dark hooded jacket, common make, sold in every Walmart in Georgia. The photo lineup administered at the store, properly, with fillers matched for age and build. The identification, immediate.

And the defendant's whereabouts that night, Detective? Did he offer an account?

He stated he was at his second job, cleaning offices at the distribution center across town, until well after midnight. We requested the time records. The center's paper timecards for that week were destroyed in a storage-room flood — the defendant's supervisor could confirm he was scheduled, but could not confirm his presence after approximately nine p.m.

So his alibi is a schedule, Lindholm said.

His alibi is unverified, Reyes said, carefully, and it was the most honest sentence of the morning.

No further questions.

Tolbert looked down the length of the bench at the defense table, and the smirk was there again, but thinner now, worn at the edges by an hour of watching a seventeen-year-old take notes like a stenographer — page after page, in a hand so even it might have been ruled, never looking up in panic, never whispering to his brother, once — only once — asking Isaiah a single question in a voice too low to carry, and writing down the answer and nodding like a man filing a fact in a drawer built for it.

Around the courtroom, the quality of attention had changed. The people in the gallery had come for a spectacle — the judge and the boy, the oversized suit, the comedy of it — and somewhere in the middle of Harold Finch's testimony they had forgotten to be entertained, the way you forget a radio is on when the news turns serious. The court reporter’s fingers moved. The clock ticked. A woman in the second row had stopped fanning herself.

Well, Tolbert said at last, and there was a new thing in his voice, not kindness, exactly, but the absence of mockery, which in that room, from that man, was a kind of weather change. "The defense may cross-examine."

Elijah stood up.

He stood up the way he had walked in, without hurry, set his pen down precisely parallel to his notebook, buttoned his father's jacket — a button made for a chest four inches broader, so the jacket bellied slightly, absurdly, and somehow not absurdly at all — and walked to the lectern with the second folder in his hand.

Good morning, Mr. Finch, he said. "I'm Elijah Carrington. I have some questions about that night, and I want you to know before I start that I believe you were frightened, and I believe you're telling this court what you honestly remember. My questions are about the remembering, sir. Not about your honesty."

Finch stared at him. Lindholm, at her table, sat very slightly forward.

Take your time, Elijah said. "There's no clock on the truth." And he opened the folder.

Mr. Finch, let's start with the store itself, Elijah said. "You've worked the night counter at the QuickMart for nine years. Is that right?"

Nine years in March.

So you know that store the way you know your own house.

I reckon I do.

Then you can help the court understand the light. Elijah glanced down at his notes once, the way a man checks a map he has already memorized. "The lights over the counter — the long fluorescent tubes. How many are there?"

There's four over the front, where the counter is.

Four tubes. And on the night of the twenty-sixth, were all four working?

Finch frowned. "I — they flicker sometimes. The one over the lottery case, it flickers."

I'm asking about that Sunday night, sir. Let me help you. Did you tell Detective Reyes, in your statement the next morning — page two, third paragraph — that one of the tubes over the counter had been out for, and I'm quoting you, 'going on a month,' and that you'd put in a work order twice?

A pause. Lindholm's pen stopped moving.

I might have said that, Finch said.

You did say it, Mr. Finch. It's in your signed statement. So on the night of the robbery, the counter was lit by three tubes out of four, and the one that was out was the one nearest the door. Is that fair?

The counter was lit fine, Finch said, and some stubbornness came into his voice, the first of the morning. "I could see."

I'm not saying you couldn't see, sir. I'm establishing where the light was. The man came through the door — the door on the left side of the store, by the ice machine. Correct?

Correct.

And he crossed to the counter. How far is that, Mr. Finch? From the door to your register.

Finch looked at the ceiling, measuring his store in his mind. "Twenty feet. Maybe twenty-five."

Twenty-two feet, according to the fire inspection diagram the State included in discovery. Elijah said it mildly, without triumph, the way you'd confirm a weather report. "And when he reached the counter, he stood on the customer side, and you stood behind it, and the counter itself is — how deep, front to back?"

Three feet, about.

So when you say he was four feet from you, sir — that was your estimate in your statement — the truth is he was never closer to you than the width of that counter plus the space he stood in. At least five feet, more likely six, and for most of the ninety seconds, farther. Am I wrong?

News in the same category

Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

45 Part