She blinked. "From? Paper's what we always—" She stopped. Her eyes went to the office door, and past it, Elijah knew from Isaiah's description, to the personnel entrance with its heavy steel door and its small square window wired with mesh. "Before the paper, Lord, that was before my time on nights. We had a keypad. No — wait. We had the cards. The swipe cards. That was the old company, before Hartline bought the building."
And the door, Elijah said, keeping his voice mild, the way Whitfield — no, the way his father, in the stories, had kept his voice mild with clerks and judges' secretaries and all the small gatekeepers of the world — "the personnel door. When Mr. Carrington comes in at night, does anything record the door?"
Tanya Cole looked at him for a long moment, and then she did something Elijah would remember: she smiled, slowly, the smile of a woman watching a young person find the handle of a door she'd forgotten was in her own wall.
The gate, she said. "Not this door. The gate out front, where the trucks come in — no. But the personnel door has a badge reader, baby. It always did. Hartline kept the old system when they bought us because ripping it out cost money. Every badge that opens that door, it writes it down somewhere. Not here." She shook her head. "The security company keeps it. Off-site, she said the man told me when they serviced it. Some office in Atlanta, computers. Meridian Site Services. The paper drowned, but that—" She pointed at the personnel door, at the small black reader beside the frame with its single red eye. "That thing don't know anything about a flood."
Elijah's hand, in his lap, closed slowly into a fist, not in anger. In something closer to prayer.
Ma'am, he said, "would you be willing to write down the name of that company for me? And the date the system was serviced? And—" He hesitated, because he had learned already that asking for everything at once made people remember they were busy. "And would you sign a statement saying the paper timecards for that week were destroyed? Not about Mr. Carrington. Just about the flood. Just what's true."
Just what's true, Tanya Cole repeated. She pulled a pad toward her. "That's a small enough thing. A body ought to be able to manage that much." She wrote in a large, looping hand, tore off the sheet, and then, after a pause, she wrote on a second sheet, in the same hand: the name of the security company, the service date, and a telephone number. "You tell that office I said to help you. Tell them Tanya Cole at the Camilla center said the boy is polite and the cause is just. It won't open any doors by itself. But it might keep one from closing in your face."
He was home before dark, and the house was quiet, Ruth at the hospital on a late shift, Isaiah asleep on the couch with one arm flung over his eyes and the monitor's green light blinking in the dim room like a small patient star. Elijah sat at the kitchen table with the case file, and Tanya Cole's two sheets of paper, and a fresh legal pad he'd bought at the dollar store with his own money, and he drafted the request the way the books said to draft it: the formal letter, the subpoena form he'd copied at the courthouse clerk's window, the careful language that asked Meridian Site Services, of Atlanta, Georgia, to produce the electronic access log for the personnel door of the Hartline distribution center, Camilla, Georgia, for the night in question, between the hours of 6:00 p.m. and 4:00 a.m., for badge number — and here he stopped, and called Isaiah's name softly, and Isaiah, surfacing from sleep, told him the number from memory the way a man recites his own birthday, because for two years that badge had been the key to the only quiet hours of his life.
Elijah wrote it down. He wrote the whole thing out twice, once in draft and once fair, and sealed the copies in envelopes, and set them by the door for the morning mail, and then he sat a while longer in the kitchen with the green light blinking across the room and thought about water, and paper, and all the truths that drown — and the one small red-eyed machine on a door that had kept its own counsel, and kept it dry.
The law corner of the Camilla public library was not a corner so much as a climate: two tall shelves of Georgia Code and case reporters at the back of the building, where the air ran cooler and the light fell in dusty bars from the high windows, and a scarred oak table that the librarians left, by unspoken agreement, to the old men who read the newspaper through magnifiers and to Elijah Carrington, who had been reading there since he was fifteen and had worn a path in the carpet that Mrs. Abernathy the head librarian pretended not to notice.
He was there on a Thursday afternoon with the discovery file and three reporters open in a fan — he was hunting the law of identification testimony, building the brief he would need if Finch ever took the stand at trial — when a shadow fell across the page and stayed there, and a voice said, from somewhere above him:
You're reading the headnotes, boy. The headnotes are what the publisher's interns thought the case said. Read the dissent first. The dissent is where the losing side tells you where the majority cheated.