Judge Raymond Tolbert retired on the last Friday of September, and the dinner in his honor was held in the fellowship hall of the First Baptist Church because the courthouse rotunda, the county commissioners decided, was too small for the man's forty years and too echoing for the speeches. There were folding tables with white cloths, and a sheet cake with a gavel piped onto it in blue icing, and three hundred people who had been sentenced by him, employed by him, opposed by him, or raised by him, moving through the hall in their good clothes with plates in their hands. Elijah came with Ruth on his arm, Ruth in a dress the color of ripe plums, and he was shown to his seat by a deputy who had once stood bailiff in Tolbert's court — and the seat, when he reached it, was at the judge's own table, at the judge's right hand, where the place card in Tolbert's own unmistakable back-slanted hand read, simply: E. Carrington.
Tolbert was seventy and thinner than he had been on the bench, and out of the robe he looked like what he had been before it: a country lawyer with a long memory and a face that kept its opinions until it was ready. He had made his speech already — short, funny in the dry places, refusing all grandeur — and he had thanked the county, and his late wife, and his clerks, and "the defendants, who taught me more than the bar association ever did," and the hall had applauded until the rafters complained. Now, over coffee, with the noise of the room settled around them like water around a stone, he took from his breast pocket a small leather case, worn at the corners to the color of honey, and set it on the table between himself and Elijah, and pushed it across with one finger, the way old men in Camilla slid important things across tables, without ceremony, so the ceremony would not frighten the thing being given.
My reading glasses lived in that for thirty-one years, Tolbert said. "The glasses themselves I've still got, and need, so you're getting the case empty, which my wife would have called a Tolbert gift if she'd lived to see the night — all container and no content." He turned the case once with his fingertip. "But I find the container is the point, son. I want you to keep whatever you read the world with, in it. And I want to say a thing to you that I have owed this table for a year."
The table had gone quiet in the way tables do when a man of Tolbert's habits clears his throat at that particular pitch.
On the first day you walked into my courtroom, Tolbert said, "in a suit that fit you like a flag on a pole, I laughed. Not out loud. Worse than out loud — I laughed the way a man laughs inside, where he thinks it doesn't count. And I said, 'We'll see how long that confidence holds.' I have sat on that bench for forty years, Mr. Carrington, and I have misjudged evidence, and I have misjudged witnesses, and once, memorably, I misjudged a lunch order and sentenced a ham sandwich to contempt —" the table broke up, and he let it, and then he raised one finger and the quiet came back like a tide obeying him — "but I do not believe I ever misjudged a human being in that room as thoroughly as I misjudged you, nor with as much company. The record already holds my apology, and it was sincerely made. But a record is a cold place to keep a thing. I wanted it warm, at a table, with cake." He picked up the glasses case and put it, this time, directly into Elijah's hand. "We'll see how long that confidence holds. It held. That's the whole of my remarks."
Elijah closed his fingers around the worn leather. He thought of the smirk, the sideways grin that had turned his stomach on the first morning, and of the boy who had stood in it and not flinched, and he understood, sitting there, that the boy and the judge had both been carried to this table by the same river, and that the river's name was time, and that time, given half a chance and a whole lot of stubbornness, was the only appellate court that never once got it wrong.
Judge, he said, "I kept the confidence because the case was my brother's. I don't know that I'd have held it for myself." He turned the case over in his hand. "Maybe that's the thing to learn at school. How to hold it for people whose names I don't know yet."
That's not a thing they teach, Tolbert said, and stood, and offered his hand across the table as the hall began to stir toward its goodbyes. "That's the thing the teaching is for." They shook hands, the judge who had laughed and the boy who had not flinched, and the grip was a workingman's grip on both sides, and neither of them hurried to end it. "Go on now. Be as good as you were in my courtroom and better than I was in it. That's a low bar in one direction and a high one in the other, and you're equal to both."
On the church steps afterward, in the cooling dark, Harold Whitfield fell in beside him with his hands in his pockets and his tie loosened, looking out at the parking lot emptying in headlights and dust. "You know what that was, in there," Whitfield said. "That was a man amending his own record. Forty years I watched Raymond Tolbert, and I opposed him in that courtroom more times than I can count, and I will tell you a thing I have told no living soul: I never once saw him do that for a lawyer. Not