Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

Chapter 4

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

He had slept three hours. He had laid out the three folders in order, the way Marcus arranged a file: the state's story, the paper, the questions. He had put the Code in the briefcase last, on top, because it was the heaviest thing he owned.

And in the morning, at the courthouse steps, Ruth had said only one thing, with her nurse's badge still clipped to her coat: "Elijah. Whatever happens in there — you are not your daddy, and you don't have to be. You just have to be the one who read it twice."

He had nodded. Then he had walked up the steps, through the metal detector, and down the hall, and the briefcase had swung at his side like it remembered the way.

The State calls Harold Finch.

He came in from the witness door slowly, holding the rail of the jury box as he passed it, a man of sixty-two with a sunburned neck and a checked shirt buttoned to the throat, and he put his hand on the Bible and swore to tell the truth in a voice that shook once, at the start, and then settled. Harold Finch had worked the night counter at the QuickMart on Route 19 for nine years. He had a wife named Doris and a grandson in the Marines and a reputation in Camilla for extending credit to people whose names he wrote on index cards he kept in a recipe box by the register, and the gallery, watching him climb into the witness chair, was watching one of their own — which was, Elijah understood, exactly the point of calling him first. The State's case was not made of paper. It was made of Harold Finch.

Andrea Lindholm stood with her file open and her voice at the temperature of a good schoolteacher, and she walked him through it gently, the way you walk a man across a floor you know is uneven.

Mr. Finch, tell the court where you were on the night of Sunday the twenty-sixth, at about eleven twenty p.m.

I was at work, Finch said. "At the QuickMart. I work the night shift, ten to six. I was behind the counter, same as always."

And what happened at eleven twenty?

Finch's hands found each other in his lap and held on. "A man come in the door. The bell went — we got a bell over the door, it rings when it opens. I looked up and he was already halfway to the counter, and he had a jacket on, a dark jacket, with the hood down, and he had a gun in his hand. Not pointed at first. Just — there. In his hand, down by his side, like he wanted me to see it but he wasn't in a hurry about it." He swallowed. "He said, 'Register. All of it. Don't be stupid.' Those were his words. Don't be stupid."

Did you comply?

I opened the register and I took out the money and I put it in a bag, one of our bags, the white ones. Four hundred and twelve dollars, near as the count came out after. He took it with — he took the bag, and he went out the door, and I hit the silent alarm and I called 911 after, when my hands would work.

How long was he in the store, Mr. Finch?

Ninety seconds. Maybe less. It felt like a year and it felt like nothing, both.

Now, Lindholm said, and her voice changed by half a degree, "did you see the man's face?"

I saw it plain. Finch looked, for the first time, directly at the defense table, and his eyes rested on Isaiah with the terrible certainty of a man who has rehearsed a moment in the dark for three weeks. "That's him. That's the man. He's sitting right there."

A sound went through the gallery, low, like wind finding a gap. Isaiah did not move. Under the table his hand had gone flat and still on his knee, and Elijah, beside him, wrote in his notebook: Finch — saw it plain — no hesitation — 3 weeks of looking at one photograph. Then he underlined photograph twice, and kept his face exactly as it was, because Lindholm was already moving to the lineup.

Mr. Finch, after the robbery, did Detective Reyes show you a set of photographs?

She did. Six pictures, laid out on the counter at the store, two days after. She told me the man might or might not be in them and I didn't have to pick nobody. I want that said — she said it right.

And what did you do?

I picked him out. Finch nodded toward Isaiah again. "That one. Number four. I picked him without hesitation. I'd know that face. He was four feet from me, across my own counter, under my own lights. You don't forget a face that has a gun attached to it."

No further questions at this time, Your Honor.

Tolbert turned his head, slow, like a man turning toward a noise he expects to enjoy. "Detective Reyes."

Paula Reyes took the stand in a gray suit with her badge clipped at her waist, twenty years a deputy and six a detective, and she summarized the investigation in the flat, numbered cadence of a woman reading a road she has driven many times. The call at 11:26 p.m. The store's camera system, which had been malfunctioning for a month — a fact she delivered without emphasis, the way you mention weather — so there was no video of the robbery itself. A customer at the gas pumps, one Marla Denny, who had seen a dark

News in the same category

Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

45 Part