A Police Officer Slapped a Black Woman in the Courthouse, Certain She Was a Criminal—Until a Bailiff Called Her “Your Honor” and Exposed His Secret

Chapter 12

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

He hesitated for only a second longer, and then he nodded and wrote something else in his notepad, and a few minutes later, after he had spoken briefly into his radio, he came back to me with a slip of paper. He held it out, and I took it with my left hand, because my right hand was still holding my folded court calendar, creased from being carried against my briefcase, its edges soft from use. The number was written in his quick, slanted hand, and I read it twice to make sure I had it right. Then I turned my calendar over in my hand and wrote the number on the back of it, in my own hand, in pencil, pressing hard enough that the letters would not fade. The calendar was already full of my notes for the day, times and names and reminders in the margins, and now, on the back, in a space that had been blank, there was a number that tied this hallway to a file that would exist long after the crowd had gone home.

I folded the calendar again, carefully, and slipped it into the pocket of my robe. It felt heavier than it had that morning, not because of the paper itself but because of what was now written on it. I had carried that calendar into the courthouse every day for years, and it had always been a tool for keeping track of the court's business. Now it was also a record of something that had happened to me, and I knew I would keep it, not because I did not trust the system to keep its own record, but because I had learned that a person should hold onto the thread of her own case, even when she is a judge, even when she is told that everything will be taken care of.

The elevator had broken down that morning. That was why I was on foot in the fourth-floor hallway at all, why I had not taken the lift from the lobby to the sixth floor as I usually did, why I had climbed the stairs with my briefcase and my calendar and my papers, moving slowly past the third floor and up to the fourth, where I had paused to catch my breath and to check the time. I had not thought much of it at the time. Elevators break down. The courthouse is an old building, and its systems fail in small, inconvenient ways, and the staff had put up a sign by the doors that morning, handwritten, saying the lift was out of service and asking people to use the stairs. I had seen the sign. I had read it without really registering it, the way you read signs in a building you know well, and I had taken the stairs without complaint, because there was no other way to get where I needed to go.

Now the broken elevator mattered in a way I had not anticipated. It mattered because it explained why I had been in that hallway at that hour, on foot, with my papers in my hands, instead of stepping out of a lift and into a different corridor. It mattered because it meant that other people had also been on foot that morning, clerks and attorneys and members of the public, moving up and down the stairwells, crowding the hallways in a way they would not have if the lift had been working. And it mattered because the security radio traffic from the time the elevator broke down would show who had been where, and when, and what had been said over the air in the minutes before I had reached the fourth floor. I had already asked for the hallway recordings to be preserved, and now I asked, quietly, for the radio traffic to be preserved as well, from the time the elevator had been reported out of service onward. The officer wrote that down too, and I saw him underline it, as if he understood that this was not a detail to be lost.

I thought about how ordinary that climb had been, how unremarkable, how much like every other morning, with no warning in it. I had simply been a judge on her way to work, carrying a motion she needed to review, taking the stairs because the elevator was broken. The question that would not go away, the one that had begun to form even as Miller was being led away, was why. Why me. Why here. Why this morning. I did not have an answer, but the question stayed with me, quiet and persistent, underneath the pain in my cheek and the noise of the crowd and the sound of the rain.

News in the same category

A Police Officer Slapped a Black Woman in the Courthouse, Certain She Was a Criminal—Until a Bailiff Called Her “Your Honor” and Exposed His Secret

45 Part