A Police Officer Slapped a Black Woman in the Courthouse, Certain She Was a Criminal—Until a Bailiff Called Her “Your Honor” and Exposed His Secret

Chapter 25

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Judge Bennett was handling the morning appearances."

I know Judge Bennett. He runs a crowded courtroom and prefers moving his calendar efficiently to giving speeches about procedure. I have sat in his courtroom and watched him work through a morning docket with the steady, unsentimental pace of a man who believes that the calendar is a promise to the people waiting on it. He does not linger. He does not lecture. He calls the case, he listens to what needs to be heard, he rules, and he moves on. It is not a style I would choose for myself, but I respect it, because I understand what it costs to keep a crowded courtroom moving without letting it become careless. A man like that would have called Maya Reynolds's case at nine, or as close to nine as the morning allowed. A man like that would have had her record in front of him.

"And the warrant?"

"There wasn't one issued this morning."

I stare at her. "Are you certain?"

"As far as the clerk's record shows."

I stare at her for a moment longer, because the words do not quite settle. There wasn't one issued this morning. As far as the clerk's record shows. The clerk's record is the record. It is not a rumor. It is not an impression. It is the official account of what the court did and did not do, and if the clerk's record shows no warrant issued that morning, then no warrant was issued that morning. I think about the hallway again, about Miller stepping toward me, about the certainty in his voice when he spoke to me, about the way he acted as if he were carrying out an order that could not be questioned. And I think about how easily that certainty could have been mistaken for authority, by me, by Thomas, by anyone who happened to be standing nearby.

There was no warrant. Maya Reynolds had checked in before nine. She was not late. She was not missing. She was not in violation of anything that morning, as far as the record showed. And yet Miller had been looking for her, and when he found me instead, he had acted as if the search itself justified whatever came next.

I pick up the ice pack again, more because my hand needs something to do than because the cold is helping now. The cold has gone numb against my skin, and the numbness is almost worse than the ache, because it makes it harder to tell what is actually happening underneath. I press it gently against my cheek and I look at Margaret, and I try to put the unease into words, because putting it into words is the only way I know to keep it from becoming something larger and less precise.

"Margaret, what did he have? What did he actually have to go on?"

She understands the question. She does not ask me to clarify it. "Thomas said the description was limited."

"How limited?"

"Black female. Approximately forty. Dark clothing. Fourth-floor courtroom."

I repeat the words in my mind, slowly, because I want to be certain I have heard them correctly. Black female. Approximately forty. Dark clothing. Fourth-floor courtroom. That is not a description. That is a category. That is a set of characteristics so broad that it could describe a dozen women in this building on any given morning, and on this particular morning it described at least two: Maya Reynolds, and me.

I am a Black woman. I am in my forties. I was wearing dark clothing that morning, the dark suit I wear when I want to be taken seriously without having to ask for it, the suit I have worn to this courthouse more times than I can count. I was on the fourth floor, walking toward my courtroom, holding a folded calendar. If you took those four facts and stripped away everything else — my name, my robe, my position, the fact that I have presided in this building for years, the fact that Thomas and Evelyn and half the staff on this floor know my face — you would be left with a description that fit me as neatly as it fit Maya Reynolds. And Miller had stripped away everything else. Or he had never bothered to look for it in the first place.

"He had never met Maya Reynolds," Margaret says, and her voice is careful, as if she is laying out facts she has verified and does not want to overstate. "As far as we know, he had no photograph."

"No photograph," I say.

"No photograph that has been produced."

News in the same category

A Police Officer Slapped a Black Woman in the Courthouse, Certain She Was a Criminal—Until a Bailiff Called Her “Your Honor” and Exposed His Secret

45 Part