A Police Officer Slapped a Black Woman in the Courthouse, Certain She Was a Criminal—Until a Bailiff Called Her “Your Honor” and Exposed His Secret

Chapter 5

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

I think, too, of Evelyn Price, my judicial assistant, who will be waiting in chambers with the morning calendar already laid out, with the files in order and the coffee made the way I like it, and who will hear about this hallway before I have a chance to tell her myself. Evelyn is fifty-eight, steady and unflappable, and she has worked with me long enough to know when I am angry and when I am only tired. She will take one look at the handkerchief, at the blood, at the way Thomas is standing, and she will understand without needing an explanation. I do not want her to learn it from a hallway rumor. I want to walk into chambers myself, with my briefcase in my hand, and tell her what happened in my own words. That thought steadies me. It gives me something ordinary to move toward, beyond this moment: the door to chambers, the desk, the calendar, the work that is waiting. The morning calendar will not wait for me to recover. It will go on, as it always does, with people who have arrived early and people who are still finding their way, and I will need to be ready for it. But first, I need to finish what is happening here, in this hallway, with this officer, while the facts are still fresh and the witnesses are still present.

My lip throbs. I press my tongue gently against the inside of it, testing the place where the skin has broken, and I taste blood again. It is not a great deal of blood. It is enough to matter. Enough to be seen. Enough to be documented, later, when the time comes for that. For now, I keep my attention on Miller. He is still standing where Thomas placed him, his hands visible, his eyes moving. I can see the tension in his shoulders, the way his uniform sits slightly askew where he moved too quickly. He is breathing faster than he was a moment ago. I wonder if he is aware of it. I wonder if he is aware of how much of himself he is showing in this hallway — the reach for the radio, the glance toward the stairs, the hesitation before every answer. A man who is certain of his actions does not look for an exit while he is explaining them. A man who is certain does not need to be told to keep his hands where they can be seen. Miller needs to be told. That tells me more than any statement he has made so far.

"Officer Miller," I say, "please step away from me."

My voice is steady. I am grateful for that steadiness, though I know it is not the absence of feeling. It is the discipline of feeling held in check by purpose. I have spoken to officers in hallways before, as a defender, when my clients were frightened and the officers were impatient. I have learned that a calm voice does not always calm the other person, but it does keep the record clear. It leaves no room for anyone to say later that I shouted, that I provoked, that I lost control. I will not give Miller that room.

His jaw moves. He is chewing on a response he has not yet formed, or perhaps biting back a response he knows he should not give. "Your Honor, I believed you were a defendant who was attempting to avoid a scheduled appearance."

"You believed I was Maya Reynolds."

"Yes."

"Have you ever met Ms. Reynolds?"

He hesitates. "No, ma'am."

"Did you have a photograph?"

"I had a description."

"What description?"

"Black female. Approximately forty. Dark clothing. Fourth-floor courtroom."

Thomas lowers his eyes. I wait. I have waited through silences like this many times — in interview rooms, in courtrooms, in hallways where a witness was deciding how much truth to offer. Silence is not empty. It is where a person decides what kind of account they are going to give. I let it lengthen. I let Miller feel the weight of his own description, how little it contained, how much he built upon it. Black female. Approximately forty. Dark clothing. Fourth-floor courtroom. That was enough, in his mind, to justify stopping a woman in a hallway, to justify raising his voice, to justify putting his hands on her. That was enough to justify a slap.

Miller adds, "There was supposed to be an outstanding warrant if she failed to appear."

"Was there an outstanding warrant?"

"She was late."

"That wasn't my question."

His gaze travels toward the staircase. I follow it, briefly, and then bring my attention back to his face. He is not looking at me. He is looking for a way to answer without answering, for a phrase that will sound like verification without being verification. I have heard that kind of answer before, from witnesses who wanted to be helpful without being accurate, from officers who wanted to be confident without being certain. It is a particular kind of evasion, and I recognize it at once.

"I would have verified."

"When?"

He doesn't answer.

News in the same category

A Police Officer Slapped a Black Woman in the Courthouse, Certain She Was a Criminal—Until a Bailiff Called Her “Your Honor” and Exposed His Secret

45 Part