A Police Officer Slapped a Black Woman in the Courthouse, Certain She Was a Criminal—Until a Bailiff Called Her “Your Honor” and Exposed His Secret

Chapter 23

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Margaret Whitcomb came through the door of my chambers, and I knew before I looked up that it was her. No one else in this building entered a judge's chambers that way, and no one else would have dared to, not even on a morning like this one. Evelyn would have knocked twice and waited. Thomas would have knocked once and waited longer. Margaret simply came in, the way she had come into courtrooms for more than twenty years, as if the room itself understood that she belonged there and would make space for her.

She is sixty-two, silver-haired, and composed with the practiced precision of someone who has served on the bench for more than two decades. I have watched her preside over arraignments that threatened to become shouting matches and settle them with a single raised hand. I have watched her listen to a defense attorney make an argument she clearly disagreed with and still give him the full courtesy of her attention, because she believed that the process itself was the point. She supported my appointment when several influential attorneys suggested I lacked the appropriate temperament for the position. I have never forgotten that. At the time, I was still close enough to my fifteen years as a public defender to know exactly what those attorneys meant, and exactly how little they understood about what temperament actually requires. Temperament is not softness. Temperament is not deference. Temperament is the discipline to remain still when everything in you wants to move, and Margaret had seen that in me when others had only seen a woman who had spent her career arguing the other side of the courtroom.

She stopped when she saw my face.

"Dear God."

"Good morning, Margaret."

She doesn't smile. I did not expect her to. Margaret Whitcomb does not offer comfort she does not mean, and she does not pretend that a thing is smaller than it is in order to make the room more comfortable. She crossed the carpet in three measured steps and stood looking down at me, her eyes moving from the swelling along my cheek to the ice pack in my hand to the folded court calendar on my desk, which I had been holding as if it were something that could steady me. I realized, in that moment, that I had not put it down since I sat down. My fingers had found its edge and stayed there.

"Tell me who did this."

"Officer Bradley Miller."

She repeated the name once, quietly, as if she were committing it to a record that already existed somewhere in her mind. "Was he assigned to courthouse security?"

"Not permanently. He was here for a scheduled appearance."

She sat across from me. She did not sit the way visitors sit, perched and ready to leave. She sat the way a judge sits when a matter is before her and will not be rushed: her back straight, her hands folded in her lap, her attention entirely on the person speaking. The chair opposite my desk is not a comfortable chair. It was chosen, I suspect, by someone who believed that visitors to a judge's chambers should not linger. Margaret made it look like a bench.

"Thomas gave me a brief account."

"Then you know enough to begin preserving the evidence."

"I've already requested the recordings."

"From every camera covering the fourth floor."

"Yes."

"All security radio traffic from the time the elevator broke down."

"Josephine."

I heard the caution in her voice, and I heard something else underneath it, too. Not disagreement. Not dismissal. A recognition that I was speaking quickly, and that the speed was not panic but precision, the same precision I had used for fifteen years when I needed a record made before anyone had time to soften it. I had spent my career as a public defender watching evidence disappear in the space between an incident and an investigation, watching a recording become unavailable, watching a report become a summary, watching a summary become a memory. I knew how quickly a morning could be rewritten if no one insisted on the originals while they still existed.

"And the original incident reports. Not revised summaries."

Margaret leans forward. "I understand."

I look at her for several seconds. I did not look away. I did not soften what I was about to say, because softening it would have been a form of asking permission, and I was not asking permission.

"Do you?"

She waits. She does not fill the silence. That is one of the things I have always admired about her, and one of the things that has always made her difficult to read. She can wait through a silence that would make most people rush to explain themselves. She lets the question stand in the room until the person who asked it has to decide whether they meant it.

"Because this isn't going to become an unfortunate misunderstanding between a police officer and a judge."

News in the same category

A Police Officer Slapped a Black Woman in the Courthouse, Certain She Was a Criminal—Until a Bailiff Called Her “Your Honor” and Exposed His Secret

45 Part