A Police Officer Slapped a Black Woman in the Courthouse, Certain She Was a Criminal—Until a Bailiff Called Her “Your Honor” and Exposed His Secret

Chapter 38

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

When he left, Evelyn closed the door again, and I sat alone in my chambers as the light outside my window began to change. The building was quieter now. The day's cases had been called. The benches were emptying. The elevator was still broken, and I thought about how much of the morning had turned on that broken elevator, on a crowd forced into a narrow corridor, on a description that was never verified, on a complaint that was buried months ago and surfaced only because the review had followed the paper. I thought about Maya Reynolds, still waiting to be heard in her own voice. I had not heard her testimony. I was not supposed to have heard it yet. The review was moving toward its findings, piece by piece, document by document, recording by recording, and the findings would be brought to me through Margaret and the supervisor, as they had been brought to me all day. What remained was for Maya to speak, for herself, about the complaint she had filed, about the building she lived in, about the morning she checked in before nine and did nothing wrong and found her name written into a statement she had not witnessed. That hearing was still ahead. I did not know when it would happen, or what she would say, or how her voice would sound when she said it, but I knew that it would happen, and that it would be heard, and that the record would hold it alongside everything else. I sat with that knowledge, and with the ache in my cheek, and with the question that would not go away, and I waited for the review to bring me what it had found next.

The findings did not arrive all at once. They arrived the way the truth arrives in a courthouse when no one is trying to hurry it or bury it — in pieces, through proper channels, each one signed, each one dated, each one placed on the record by someone whose job it was to place it there. A letter from the independent review came to my chambers through Evelyn, in a sealed envelope, logged in the way all such correspondence is logged. A second letter came to Chief Judge Margaret Whitcomb. A third went to the county administrator. None of them came to me directly in a hallway. None of them came as a whisper. That was the point, and I understood it as I sat at my desk that morning and read the first page with my hands folded on the blotter, the rain still moving down the tall windows behind me.

The review had done what a review is supposed to do. It had taken the hallway recordings from every camera covering the fourth floor and watched them in order, without sound first and then with sound, noting the time stamps the way a clerk notes a docket. It had taken all the security radio traffic from the time the elevator broke down and transcribed it, every call and every answer, every pause where a voice waited for a reply that did not come. It had taken the original incident reports, not the revised summaries, and laid them side by side so that the differences could be seen plainly. It had taken the photographs of my cheek, the papers scattered across the corridor floor, the fallen briefcase, the corridor itself with its scuffed baseboards and its fluorescent light. It had taken the cell phone camera recording from the crowd, the one that had shaken in someone's hand and still held steady enough to show what it showed. It had taken the incident number I had written on the back of a folded court calendar, in my own hand, in the minutes after I was struck, when my hand was still shaking and I wrote it down anyway because the record matters more than the shaking.

I did not investigate any of it. I had not gone looking for it, and I did not go looking for it now. That separation was not distance. It was the discipline that makes the robe mean something. My part was to tell the truth about what happened to me, to preserve what I had preserved, to answer when I was asked, and then to step back and let the process do the work it exists to do. Fifteen years as a public defender had taught me what happens when the process is bent to serve a person instead of the other way around. I had watched good cases fall apart because someone cut a corner to help, and I had watched bad facts get dressed up because someone wanted an outcome more than they wanted the truth. I would not do that now, not even for my own case. Especially not for my own case.

What the review still needed, and what it had asked for through the proper proceeding, was Maya Reynolds.

I had thought about her every day since that morning. Not as an abstraction. As a woman in dark clothing, about forty years old, who had checked in before nine for a case on the nine o'clock calendar before Judge Bennett on the fourth floor. A defendant. A woman who had come to court to answer for something, as thousands of people do, and who had found herself at the center of a morning that was never about her case at all, but about keeping her from ever reaching it. I had not spoken to her since. I had not sought her out. The review had made it clear, through counsel and through the court administrator, that her testimony would be taken in the proper proceeding, with notice to all parties, with a record made, with no one from my chambers present except as a witness if called. That was as it should be. She did not belong to my story. She belonged to her own.

News in the same category

A Police Officer Slapped a Black Woman in the Courthouse, Certain She Was a Criminal—Until a Bailiff Called Her “Your Honor” and Exposed His Secret

45 Part