I learned to tell the difference by watching hands and feet. The people who wanted to help moved closer, slowly, their hands open at their sides, their eyes on the person who was frightened rather than on the officer. They were the ones who would say, "I saw what happened," later, in a hallway or a courtroom, when saying it cost them something. The people who wanted to make sure they didn't become the next person involved stood farther back, near a wall or a doorway, their weight already shifted toward an exit. They were not cruel. They were careful. They had learned, as so many of my clients had learned, that proximity to a police encounter could become participation in it, and participation could become a charge, and a charge could become a record that followed them long after the hallway was empty.
I remember standing in a different courthouse hallway, years ago, beside a young man who had been brought in for a hearing he did not understand. He was nineteen, and he kept asking me what the words on the paper meant, and I kept translating them into plain language while an officer stood a few feet away, arms crossed, watching us as if our conversation itself were a problem to be managed. A small crowd had formed then, too — clerks with files in their arms, a family waiting for another courtroom, a janitor with a cart who had stopped pushing it. None of them moved when I asked for room. None of them meant any harm. They were simply trying to see, and to be seen seeing, because in a courthouse, being seen can be the only protection a person has.
I remember another morning, in another hallway, when a mother waited for her son's case to be called and an officer raised his voice at her for standing in the wrong place. She did not raise hers back. She lowered her eyes and moved, and I watched her hands shake as she folded them in front of her. Later, in my office, she told me she had not been afraid of being arrested. She had been afraid of being misunderstood, of having a moment of confusion written down as defiance. That fear stayed with me long after I took the bench. It is the fear I see now in the faces around me — not panic, but calculation. They are deciding how close they can stand without becoming part of this.
The woman near the elevator shifts her weight again. She is holding a purse in front of her with both hands, as if it might shield her. A man in a suit, perhaps a lawyer on his way to an early conference, has stopped with his briefcase in his hand and his mouth slightly open. A young woman with a lanyard around her neck is looking at her phone, then at me, then at her phone again, as if she cannot decide whether to keep recording or to put it away. I do not blame any of them for staying. I do not blame them for watching. I have stood where they are standing, and I know what it costs to look away from something you have just witnessed.
I think of the waiting areas outside the courtrooms where I spent so much of my working life before I took the bench. They were not grand places. They were rows of hard benches under fluorescent light, with a water fountain that ran too cold and a clock that ran a few minutes fast, and people sat there holding papers they did not fully understand, waiting for a name to be called. I learned to arrive early in those rooms, not because I loved the quiet, but because my clients needed someone to sit beside them while they waited. A man who had worked a night shift would arrive with his uniform still on, his eyes heavy, asking me if the judge would understand that he had come straight from work. A woman who had taken three buses to get to court would arrive with a child asleep against her shoulder, asking me if she could bring the child inside. I would answer as plainly as I could, and I would watch their shoulders lower a fraction when they realized that someone in the building was speaking to them, not past them.
Those mornings taught me something I have carried onto the bench: a courthouse is not only a place where the law is applied. It is a place where people arrive already afraid, already tired, already certain that a mistake — a wrong hallway, a late bus, a misunderstood instruction — could cost them dearly. They watch officers the way they watch weather, looking for a sign of what the day will bring. They gather in hallways because the hallway is where the first decision is made, often before a judge ever sees the file: who is believed, who is stopped, who is allowed to pass.