A Police Officer Slapped a Black Woman in the Courthouse, Certain She Was a Criminal—Until a Bailiff Called Her “Your Honor” and Exposed His Secret

Chapter 9

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

He studied me. His eyes moved from my face to the papers on the floor, to the briefcase lying on its side a few feet away, to the people standing along the walls with their hands clasped and their coats still damp from the rain outside. He did not argue. He did not tell me again that I was hurt, though we both knew I was. He simply held my gaze for a long moment, and then he nodded.

"All right," he said.

That was all. It was enough. In that small exchange I felt the shape of the morning change. I was not going to be carried out of this hallway as a person to be looked after. I was going to stay in it until what had happened here had been fixed in place by something more reliable than memory.

I turned, slowly, because turning too fast made the pain move, and I looked for the nearest officer who was not part of what had just happened. There were several in the corridor now, drawn by the radio traffic and the noise and the crowd, and I chose the one who seemed to be waiting for someone to tell him what to do. He was younger than Miller, with a neat uniform and a notepad already in his hand, and when I spoke to him I kept my voice level and clear, the voice I use when I am reading a ruling and want every word to be heard in the back row.

"I need three things done now, and I need them done separately," I said. "First, I need an independent supervisor to document my injuries. Not someone from Officer Miller's immediate chain, if that can be arranged. Someone who has no connection to him and no connection to this incident. I want the documentation to be thorough and I want it to be done by a person who will not be asked later to explain why they were also doing something else at the same time."

He wrote that down, his pen moving quickly.

"Second," I said, "I need the names of the witnesses collected. Everyone who was in this hallway when it happened, and everyone who arrived in the minute after. I do not want anyone to leave without giving a name and a way to be reached, and I do not want anyone's account to be summarized by someone else. If a person saw it, I want that person's own name on the list."

"Yes, Your Honor," he said.

"Third," I said, "I need the hallway recordings preserved immediately. Every camera covering the fourth floor. Not reviewed, not copied for convenience later, preserved. I want a record made now that the recordings have been secured, and I want to know who secured them and when."

He nodded again, and then he hesitated, as if he were waiting for a fourth instruction that would make this easier to carry out. I looked at Thomas, who was still standing at my elbow, still watching the corridor, still keeping himself between me and the thickest part of the crowd without making a show of it.

"Thomas," I said, and I made sure my voice was firm enough that the officer beside us would hear it too, "I need you to hear this clearly. You are not to make yourself the investigator here."

He turned his head toward me, surprised. I had seen that look before, in courtrooms, when I had ruled against a lawyer who had expected to win on sympathy alone.

"You witnessed part of what happened," I said. "You were standing here. You saw it. That makes your testimony important, and it makes it separate. Your testimony needs to remain separate from the court administration's response. If you start collecting statements and directing officers and deciding what gets preserved, then later someone will be able to say that the response was shaped by a witness. I will not let that happen to your account, and I will not let it happen to this process."

He was quiet for a moment. I could see him weighing it, the way he weighs everything, slowly and without hurry, as if haste itself were a kind of carelessness. He has spent years keeping order in my courtroom, and I knew that part of him wanted to take charge of this hallway the way he takes charge of a crowded docket, by stepping forward and sorting it out. But he is also a man who understands procedure, who understands that doing the right thing in the wrong role can spoil the right thing entirely.

"I understand," he said at last.

"Thank you," I said. "I need you here, with me. That is your place in this. Not out there gathering the record. Here."

He nodded once, and I saw something settle in his shoulders, not relief exactly, but acceptance. The officer with the notepad had been listening, and I could see him writing faster now, as if he understood that what I was saying to Thomas was also an instruction to him, that the lines between witness and administrator were not to be blurred by good intentions.

News in the same category

A Police Officer Slapped a Black Woman in the Courthouse, Certain She Was a Criminal—Until a Bailiff Called Her “Your Honor” and Exposed His Secret

45 Part