Thomas stayed beside me through all of it, a kind of steadiness, not speaking unless he was spoken to, not moving unless I moved. He watched the officers work, the crowd, the doors to the courtrooms. His knees must have been aching from standing so long, but he did not shift his weight in a way that would have drawn attention to it. He has always borne discomfort without comment. I thought of the years he has spent in this building, the mornings he has opened courtrooms before anyone else arrived, the quiet, unrecorded work of keeping a courthouse running, and how much of that work is invisible until something goes wrong.
When the supervisor had finished her notes and the officer with the camera had finished her photographs, and when the witness list had grown long enough that the officer with the clipboard had to turn to a second page, I looked down at the papers still scattered on the floor. They had been documented. They had been photographed from above and from the side, with the footprints and the bent corners and the upside-down photograph of the damaged building all visible. The scene had been preserved as it was, not as it should have been. Only then did I allow myself to think about gathering them up.
Thomas bent to retrieve my belongings once the scene had been documented. I watched him move slowly, his knees stiff from years of service, lowering himself with one hand braced against the wall, reaching for the nearest pages with a care that seemed out of proportion to the task, as if he were handling something fragile rather than paper. He gathered the motion first, smoothing it gently with his palm before he lifted it, and then he reached for the photograph, turning it right side up as he picked it up, and I saw him look at it for a moment, at the darkened brick and the boarded window, before he placed it on top of the stack. He moved to my briefcase next, righting it, closing the clasp with a small click, setting it upright against the wall. He did it all without hurry, without asking for help, as if this were simply the next thing that needed to be done, and I felt a sudden, sharp tenderness for him, for the slowness of his movements and the dignity with which he performed them, for the way he had spent a lifetime picking up after other people's mornings and had never once made a show of it.
"Leave those," I tell him. "I've picked up worse."
He did not stop at first. He reached for another page, one that had drifted toward the bench along the wall, and I said his name, more firmly this time, not as a judge speaking to a bailiff but as a person speaking to another person who needed to be told to stop.
"Thomas."
He straightened. He did so slowly, one hand still braced against the wall, his knees protesting audibly as he rose, and he looked at me with an expression I could not quite read, something between surprise and a kind of stubbornness.
"What?" he said.
"Thank you," I said.
For a moment he looks almost embarrassed. His eyes dropped, just for a second, to the papers in his hands, and then back to me, and I saw the colour rise slightly in his cheeks. He has never been comfortable with thanks, not in all the years I have known him. He deflects it the way some people deflect praise for doing a job they believe should not require praise at all.
"That's the job," he said.
"No," I say. "You made a choice."
He was quiet. I watched his expression change, the embarrassment giving way to something deeper, as if my words had reached a place in him that his own sense of duty had not quite named. He looked toward the office where Miller has disappeared, the door still closed, and I saw him consider what he had done in the moments after the slap, the way he had stepped forward, the way he had placed himself between me and Miller, the way he had stayed. He had not been ordered to do any of that. He had seen something happen and he had decided, in a fraction of a second, not to look away from it.
"Yes," he says. "I suppose I did."