A Police Officer Slapped a Black Woman in the Courthouse, Certain She Was a Criminal—Until a Bailiff Called Her “Your Honor” and Exposed His Secret

Chapter 28

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Margaret considers the question. "He runs a crowded courtroom. He prefers moving his calendar efficiently. If she checked in before nine, he would have called her case when he reached it on the list. I don't know where she falls on the list. I don't know whether he has reached her yet."

"And if he has?"

"Then she has appeared, and the record will show that she appeared, and the morning will have proceeded as it was supposed to proceed, except for what happened in the hallway."

"We will preserve the evidence," she says again, as if she is reminding both of us. "All of it. The recordings. The radio traffic. The original reports. We will not let this become a summary."

I nod. "And Maya Reynolds?"

Margaret's expression does not change, but I see something in it, a flicker of the same unease I am feeling, the same recognition that the woman at the center of Miller's search is also at the center of a question we have not yet answered.

"She checked in before nine," Margaret says. "That is what the preliminary record shows. Beyond that, we are still determining what happened, and why Miller was looking for her at all."

"That's what we're trying to determine," I repeat, quietly, and the words feel heavier the second time I say them. That's what we're trying to determine. It is an honest answer. It is also an incomplete one, because determination takes time, and time is what we have, and time is what the morning is giving us, minute by minute, tick by tick on the clock on my wall.

I look at the clock once more. I do not know what time it is now, exactly, because I have lost track of the minutes while Margaret and I have been talking. I know only that it is still morning, and that the day is still unfolding, and that whatever comes next will come next, whether I am ready for it or not.

Margaret reaches across the desk then, not to touch my hand, but to move the folded court calendar slightly to one side, so that it no longer sits between us like a barrier. It is a small gesture, and I understand it for what it is: an attempt to clear the space, to make room for the conversation we still need to have, the one that is not about recordings or reports or radio traffic, but about what it means to be a judge who has just been reminded, in the most personal way possible, that the system she serves does not always see people clearly.

"You did nothing wrong this morning," she says. "I want you to hear that from me, plainly, before anything else happens. You walked to your courtroom. You were stopped. You were struck. None of that was your doing."

"I know," I say, and my voice is steady, even if the thought behind it is not. "I know I did nothing wrong. Knowing it and feeling it are not the same thing, not yet."

Margaret nods. "They will be, in time. Not today. Today you only have to sit here, and tell the truth when you are asked, and let the process work."

"And remain separate," I say, and I hear the edge in my own voice, not anger at Margaret, but frustration at the position itself. "Remain separate from the investigation. Ask only who is assigned to her case, not to investigate it myself."

"Yes," Margaret says, and she does not apologize for the instruction, because she knows it is necessary, and because she knows I know it is necessary. "You are a witness. You are the person who was struck. You cannot also be the person who investigates what happened to Maya Reynolds, or why Miller was looking for her. The separation protects you, and it protects the investigation. If you involve yourself, even with the best intentions, you give someone a reason to question everything that follows."

I understand the logic. I have applied the same logic myself, from the bench, when I have recused myself from a matter because I knew a party, or because I had a prior connection to a case, or because the appearance of impartiality mattered as much as impartiality itself. I understand that separation is not a punishment. It is a safeguard. It is the system protecting itself from the appearance that a judge used her position to direct an inquiry into a matter that touched her personally. And yet understanding it does not make it easy to sit here, with an ice pack against my cheek, knowing that Maya Reynolds is somewhere in this building, and that the man who struck me was looking for her, and that I am being asked to remain separate from the very question that will not leave me alone: why was he looking for her at all?

News in the same category

A Police Officer Slapped a Black Woman in the Courthouse, Certain She Was a Criminal—Until a Bailiff Called Her “Your Honor” and Exposed His Secret

45 Part