A Police Officer Slapped a Black Woman in the Courthouse, Certain She Was a Criminal—Until a Bailiff Called Her “Your Honor” and Exposed His Secret

Chapter 24

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Nobody has suggested that."

"Someone will."

Margaret's gaze moves toward the bruising along my cheek. She does not flinch. She does not look away quickly, the way people do when they are embarrassed by someone else's injury. She looks at it the way a judge looks at an exhibit: carefully, without sentiment, registering what is there.

"Perhaps," she says. "But we won't let the courthouse handle this privately."

That is the first reassuring thing anyone has said to me.

"You've known me a long time," I said, and my voice was quieter than I intended. "You know I don't ask for special treatment."

"I know."

"You know I spent fifteen years on the other side of this building, asking judges to hold officers to the same standard as everyone else."

"I know that too."

I nodded, and the movement hurt. "Then you know why I need this handled the way it would be handled for anyone else. Not more harshly. Not more leniently. The same."

"The recordings will be secured," she said. "The radio traffic will be pulled. The reports will be the originals. I will see to it personally."

"Thank you."

She did not accept the thanks with a nod and move on. She sat with it, the way she sat with everything, and then she said, very quietly, "Josephine, are you all right?"

"I'm sitting here," I said. "That's what I can tell you right now."

Margaret nodded, as if that were an answer she could work with. "That's enough for now."

Then Margaret shifted slightly in her chair, and I saw her expression change. It was a small change, the kind of change that would have been invisible to someone who did not know her, but I knew her. I had watched her preside for years. I knew what it looked like when she was about to deliver news she had been holding until the right moment, and I knew what it looked like when that news was not simple.

"You should know there's another complication."

I sit straighter. The movement sent a fresh pulse of pain through my jaw, but I did not let it show. I set the ice pack down on my desk, carefully, as if the act of setting it down would help me listen more clearly.

"What complication?"

"The woman he thought you were."

"Maya Reynolds."

Margaret nods. "Her case was on the fourth-floor calendar this morning. She was scheduled to appear at nine."

"And?"

"She arrived."

I look at the clock. It is 9:24. The clock on my chambers wall is an old clock, the kind with a second hand that moves in small, audible ticks, and I had been aware of it since I sat down without consciously looking at it. Now I looked at it directly. Nine twenty-four. Twenty-four minutes past the hour when Maya Reynolds was scheduled to appear. Twenty-four minutes past nine, and I was sitting here with an ice pack and a swollen cheek, listening to the chief judge tell me that the woman Miller had been looking for had already arrived.

"Was she late?"

"According to the preliminary record, she checked in before nine."

I lower the ice pack. I set it on the desk beside the folded calendar and I leave my hand resting there, palm down, because I need something solid under it. "Then why was Miller looking for her?"

"That's what we're trying to determine."

A quiet unease moves through me. It is not the sharp unease of fear, or the hot unease of anger. It is quieter than that, and colder. It moves slowly, the way understanding moves when it arrives before you are ready for it. If Maya Reynolds had already checked in, the premise of Miller's confrontation was false before he ever approached me. He had not been looking for a woman who had failed to appear. He had not been looking for a woman who was late, or missing, or hiding. He had been looking for a woman who was already here, already checked in, already waiting in the system to be called. The reason he gave for stopping me, whatever words he used in that hallway, had been wrong from the start, and the wrongness of it was not a matter of interpretation. It was a matter of record. She checked in before nine. The clock said nine twenty-four. The arithmetic was simple, and the simplicity of it was what made it so unsettling.

"Who was assigned to her case?"

Margaret hesitates. It is a brief hesitation, but I notice it, because Margaret does not hesitate often, and when she does, it means she is weighing something carefully. She is weighing what to tell me, and what to hold back, and where the line falls between informing a colleague and involving a witness in an investigation that is not hers to conduct.

"Josephine, I need you to remain separate from the investigation."

I meet her eyes. I do not raise my voice. I do not need to. "I'm asking who's assigned to her case, not asking to investigate it."

News in the same category

A Police Officer Slapped a Black Woman in the Courthouse, Certain She Was a Criminal—Until a Bailiff Called Her “Your Honor” and Exposed His Secret

45 Part