A Police Officer Slapped a Black Woman in the Courthouse, Certain She Was a Criminal—Until a Bailiff Called Her “Your Honor” and Exposed His Secret

Chapter 8

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Then tell me what you're saying."

His mouth opens, but no words come. He stands there, an officer in a courthouse hallway, with a security officer waiting beside him and a crowd watching, and he has nothing to say. I do not fill the silence for him. I have learned, over fifteen years of listening to people try to explain themselves, that silence after a direct question is often more honest than any answer that follows it. It tells you where the explanation ends and the evasion begins.

The security officers escort him toward a nearby office. As he passes me, I notice his right hand shaking. It occurs to me that he might finally be afraid. I am not particularly interested in that fear. I am interested in what he was certain of five minutes earlier.

The door of the nearby office had not quite closed behind him when the hallway seemed to settle back into itself, and I understood that what had just happened was already becoming something other people would have to describe. Officer Bradley Miller was gone from my sight, escorted down the corridor by two officers I did not know well, his right hand shaking at his side, and I was left standing where he had left me, in the middle of the fourth floor, with Senior Bailiff Thomas Gallagher beside me and my papers scattered across the tile and a crowd that did not know whether to move closer or to step back. The rain was still coming down against the tall windows at the end of the hall, a steady grey wash that made the fluorescent light look thinner than it should have, and somewhere behind me a security radio crackled and then went quiet, as if the person holding it had thought better of speaking into it in front of all of us.

My cheek burned. It was not a sharp pain, not at first, but a deep, spreading heat that seemed to pulse with my own heartbeat, and when I breathed in through my nose the air felt too cold against the skin. I kept my hands at my sides. I did not want to touch my face in front of the crowd. I did not want to give anyone in that hallway a gesture they could later describe as confusion or collapse, because I was neither confused nor collapsing, and because I had spent fifteen years as a public defender learning how a single moment in a hallway could be retold until it no longer resembled itself. I had watched clients lose cases not in the courtroom but in the minutes after an incident, when no one wrote anything down and everyone agreed afterward that they remembered it differently. I knew what happened to evidence when people were kind and well-meaning and in a hurry to make a person comfortable. It disappeared.

Thomas was watching me the way he watches a courtroom when a witness is about to say something he cannot take back. He is seventy-one, slightly stooped now, with stiff knees that make him move as if every step has to be negotiated first, and he has stood outside my courtroom door for longer than I have sat behind the bench. He knows the rhythm of my mornings, the way I carry my calendar folded in my left hand, the way I stop to speak to the clerks before I go in. He stepped closer now, low enough that only I could hear him, and put a hand very lightly at my elbow, not pulling, only steadying.

"You need to sit down," he said.

I shook my head. The movement made the heat in my cheek flare and run down toward my jaw, and I had to wait a moment before I trusted my voice.

"Not yet," I said.

"Josephine," he said quietly, using my first name for the first time since I took the bench, "you're injured."

I looked at him then, really looked at him, at the lines around his eyes and the grey in his hair and the way his shoulders had gone tight under his uniform, and I understood that he was not speaking to me as a bailiff speaks to a judge. He was speaking to me as a man who had just watched something happen that should never happen in a courthouse, and who wanted, very simply, for me to be all right. It would have been easy to let him lead me to a chair. It would have been easy to let the crowd part and let someone bring water and let the whole morning soften into concern. But concern was not what I needed in that hallway, and I knew it in the same way I had known it in interview rooms and holding cells and courtrooms where a record was either made or lost.

"And we're standing in a courthouse full of people who understand how evidence disappears," I said.

News in the same category

A Police Officer Slapped a Black Woman in the Courthouse, Certain She Was a Criminal—Until a Bailiff Called Her “Your Honor” and Exposed His Secret

45 Part