A Police Officer Slapped a Black Woman in the Courthouse, Certain She Was a Criminal—Until a Bailiff Called Her “Your Honor” and Exposed His Secret

Chapter 22

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"I am going to stay right here," she says, "until the chief judge arrives. I am not going to leave you alone with this."

"Thank you."

She returns to her desk, but she does not sit all the way back. She sits on the edge of her chair, poised, ready, her eyes moving between me and the door, as if she is keeping watch over both. I am grateful for that watchfulness. It is not hovering. It is not pity. It is the steady attention of a person who has decided that her job, in this moment, is not to manage a calendar but to manage a room, to make sure that the woman sitting in the visitor's chair is safe, and seen, and not rushed into pretending that what happened did not happen.

I think about the nine o'clock calendar, about the parties who will be told that their matters have been reassigned, about the lawyers who will adjust their mornings, about the people waiting in the hallway outside another courtroom who will never know why their judge changed. They will know only that the court has made an arrangement, and that their cases will still be heard. That is as it should be. The court must go on, even when one of its judges cannot go on with it that morning. The work is larger than any one of us, and that largeness is a comfort, because it means that my absence, for a morning, does not stop justice. It only shifts it, briefly, into other capable hands.

I think about the robe hanging in the small closet beside my desk, the black robe I put on each morning with the same care my mother took with her blue dress. I have always thought of the robe as a kind of promise, a promise to listen, a promise to be fair, a promise to remember the woman who needed it. This morning, the robe was in that closet, and I was in the hallway without it, and a man looked at me and saw only a woman in ordinary clothes. I wonder, as I sit here with the ice against my face, whether the promise of the robe lives in the cloth itself or in the person who wears it. I believe now that it lives in the person, and that it must live there even when the robe is not on, even when no one can see it, even when the person measuring you cannot see it either. My mother understood that. She wore her blue dress for a celebration, but her steadiness did not come from the dress. It came from her, from the way she held my hand and stood beside me and refused to let the moment be smaller than it was.

The rain has not stopped. It taps and taps against the tall windows, steady and patient, and I listen to it the way I listened to it on ordinary mornings, when I stood at those windows with my coffee and watched the city wake up. The sound is the same. The room is the same. The photographs are the same. Only I have changed, in the space of a morning, from a judge beginning her day to a judge sitting in a visitor's chair with a mark on her face, waiting for help to arrive. That change feels large, and it feels small at the same time, large because it hurts, small because I know that pain, even this pain, is not the whole story. The whole story will be told through proper channels, in the right rooms, by the right people, and my part in it, for now, is to sit here, to hold the ice, to breathe, and to remember who I am.

I close my eyes again, briefly, and I hear my mother's voice, not as it was in the photograph, but as it was in the car on the way home from the swearing-in, when the reception was over and the blue dress was still on and she was tired and happy and quiet. She had said, "You did well today," and I had said, "I was nervous," and she had said, "Being nervous means you understand what it means." I had not known then what she meant, either. I know now. Being nervous, being afraid, being hurt, none of that means you are unfit for the work. It means you understand that the work matters, that the people who come before you matter, that the decisions you make matter, and that understanding is not a weakness. It is the reason you can be trusted with the robe at all.

A knock sounds at the door.

Chief Judge Margaret Whitcomb enters without waiting for an answer.

News in the same category

A Police Officer Slapped a Black Woman in the Courthouse, Certain She Was a Criminal—Until a Bailiff Called Her “Your Honor” and Exposed His Secret

45 Part