A Police Officer Slapped a Black Woman in the Courthouse, Certain She Was a Criminal—Until a Bailiff Called Her “Your Honor” and Exposed His Secret

Chapter 27

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"I'm thinking about the description," I say. "I'm thinking about what it means to be stopped because you match four words on a piece of paper. Black female. Approximately forty. Dark clothing. Fourth-floor courtroom. That's all he had. That's all he needed, apparently, to decide that I was the person he was looking for."

"And no photograph," Margaret says.

"And no photograph. And no warrant. And she had already checked in."

I pause, and I choose my next words carefully, because I want Margaret to understand that I am not asking her to investigate something, and I am not asking her to share information she is not ready to share. I am asking her to sit with the same question I am sitting with, because I cannot sit with it alone.

"If I were Maya Reynolds," I say, "would it have been acceptable?"

Margaret does not answer immediately. She looks at me, and I see in her eyes that she understands the question is not rhetorical, and that she understands why I am asking it. She is sixty-two years old. She has been on the bench for more than twenty years. She has seen more of this system than I have, and she has seen it from the bench, where the view is both clearer and more limited than it is from the other side of the courtroom.

"No," she says finally. "It would not have been acceptable."

"Then why does it feel as though it would have been handled differently?"

"Because it might have been," she says, and her honesty is bracing, the way cold water is bracing. "And that is something we have to be honest about, even here, even now."

I nod. I do not argue with her. There is nothing to argue with. She has said the thing that is true, and the truth of it sits in the room between us, heavy and unadorned.

"I spent fifteen years defending people who matched descriptions like that one," I say. "I stood in courtrooms and I told judges that a description is not an identification. I told them that you cannot stop a person because they resemble a category. I believed it then, and I believe it now. I just never thought I would be the person standing in the hallway, learning what it feels like when someone else decides that the description is enough."

Margaret leans forward slightly, and her voice is steady. "You were not the person he was looking for. But the fact that you were not does not make what happened to you different in kind from what would have happened to her. It makes it different in consequence, because you are a judge, and because you are sitting here, and because I am sitting across from you. That is not justice. That is visibility. And visibility is not the same thing as justice, even when it leads to the right result."

"I don't want this to be about me being a judge," I say. "I want it to be about what happened, and about whether what happened would have been wrong no matter who it happened to."

"It was wrong," Margaret says. "It was wrong when it happened to you, and it would have been wrong if it had happened to her. The record will show that. The recordings will show that. The absence of a warrant will show that. The check-in before nine will show that. The description will show that. We will make sure the record shows all of it, not just the part that is easiest to explain."

And yet the unease remains, because the tangling is the point. Miller was looking for Maya Reynolds. He found me. The premise of his search was false before he ever approached me, because she had already checked in, because there was no warrant, because the description he carried could have been anyone. The false premise does not excuse what happened. It explains it, in part, and the explanation makes it worse, not better, because it means there was no lawful basis for the confrontation in the first place. There was only a description, and a man who treated that description as sufficient, and a woman who happened to match it.

Margaret stands, briefly, to pour water from the carafe on the side table into a glass, and she sets the glass on my desk within my reach. It is a small, practical gesture, the kind of gesture a person makes when they do not know what else to do, and it touches me more than any formal reassurance could. She sits down again, and she folds her hands, and she waits.

"Tell me about Judge Bennett," I say, because I need to think about something concrete, something that will anchor me in the ordinary workings of this building. "Do you think he has already called her case?"

News in the same category

A Police Officer Slapped a Black Woman in the Courthouse, Certain She Was a Criminal—Until a Bailiff Called Her “Your Honor” and Exposed His Secret

45 Part