I sit in Evelyn's visitor chair, and I think about my mother in her blue dress, and I think about the woman I was before the robe, the public defender who sat beside people in holding cells and in interview rooms and told them, in plain language, what would happen next. I think about the way those people looked at me, sometimes with hope and sometimes with suspicion, and I think about the way I looked at judges from that side of the room, how large they seemed, how distant, how certain. I had promised myself, when I took the bench, that I would not become distant, that I would remember the weight of waiting, the fear of being misheard, the particular loneliness of sitting in a courtroom while strangers discuss your life as if you were not in the room. I had promised myself that the robe would be a responsibility, not a shield, and that I would wear it the way my mother wore her blue dress that day, carefully, and with the knowledge that what you wear for an occasion matters less than how you behave while you are wearing it.
That morning, a man in uniform looked at me and did not see a judge. He saw a defendant. He saw a woman he believed he could measure in a single glance, and he measured her as someone who could be struck. The robe did not protect me. The title did not protect me. The fifteen years did not protect me. What protected me, if anything protected me at all, was the simple fact that I remained standing, and that I knew, even in the shock of it, that I had the right to be believed, and that I had the right to ask for help through the proper channels, and that I did not have to accept what had happened as if it were an ordinary part of the morning.
My mother held my hand through the reception as though I might still be twelve years old, and I remember now that her hand was not only holding mine. It was steadying me. It was saying, without words, that I did not have to carry this alone, that pride and fear could sit side by side in the same heart, that a woman could be both strong and in need of steadying. I had laughed then, because I was happy, and because I thought the hard part was behind me. I understand now that she was preparing me for mornings like this one, mornings when the robe would not be enough, when the title would not be enough, when the only thing left would be the woman underneath, and the question of whether she could still stand on her own and ask, clearly and without shame, for what was right.
The rain taps against the tall windows. The photographs look back at me from the shelves. The certificate hangs in its plain wooden frame. My mother's blue dress is bright in the photograph, even in the grey light, and I keep my eyes on it for a moment longer than I need to, because it steadies me, the way her hand steadied me that day.
Evelyn returns with an ice pack wrapped in a towel. She carries it the way she carries everything important, with both hands, carefully, as if it might break if she hurries. The towel is white, clean, folded neatly around the pack, and I can see the faint dampness already beginning to show through the cloth. She does not ask me how I feel. She does not offer sympathy in the form of words that would require me to answer. She simply holds it out to me, and when I take it, her fingers brush mine for a moment, and that brief touch says more than any sentence could.
"Chief Judge Whitcomb is coming."
"Good."
"I've also called for medical assistance."
"Thank you."
I look at the stack of files on my desk. They are neat, as Evelyn always keeps them, each one squared at the edges, each one labeled in her clear handwriting, each one representing a person who is waiting for this morning to unfold in the way they were told it would. There are motions to be heard, pleas to be taken, sentences to be considered, and for a moment I feel the pull of that work, the ordinary responsibility of it, the sense that if I could only get to my desk and open the first file, the morning might right itself.
"Your nine o'clock calendar is being reassigned."
"Make sure the parties know."
"They'll know."
I press the ice pack against my cheek. The cold is immediate, sharp at first, and then settling into a dull numbness that eases the throbbing in my jaw. The towel keeps the worst of the cold from my skin, but I can still feel it seeping through, and I am grateful for it, because pain that can be eased is pain that can be borne, and because the act of holding something cold against my face gives my hands something to do besides trembling.