A Police Officer Slapped a Black Woman in the Courthouse, Certain She Was a Criminal—Until a Bailiff Called Her “Your Honor” and Exposed His Secret

Chapter 36

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

I tried to imagine what that must have felt like for her, and I found that I did not have to imagine very hard, because I had spent fifteen years as a public defender sitting beside defendants who had been told that their silence was the price of their safety. She was a defendant, already frightened, already aware that every word she said in this building could be weighed against her, and now she was told she was a witness for the officer who had come looking for her. If she said she had not been there, she would be contradicting a police officer. If she said nothing, his statement would stand with her name on it, as if she had agreed. If she spoke the truth, she would be afraid that her own case would suffer, that Judge Bennett would think less of her, that Miller would find another way to make her pay for speaking. The pressure was not abstract. It was specific, and it was placed on her deliberately, by a man who understood exactly how a courthouse works and exactly how frightened a defendant can be made to feel. He had named her not because she could help his account, but because naming her could hurt her if she tried to correct it. That was the second injury of the morning, quieter than the slap, harder to photograph, but no less real.

Evelyn told me that Maya had asked, through the proper channels, whether she was in trouble for something she had not done, whether naming her as a witness meant that she would be called to say something she had not seen, whether she would be believed if she said she had not been there. The questions were simple, and they were the questions of a person who had done nothing wrong and was afraid that doing nothing wrong would not be enough. I wanted to answer her myself. I wanted to tell her that she had checked in before nine, that no warrant had been issued that morning, that she had done nothing wrong, that her name in Miller's statement did not make her a witness to something she had not seen. But I could not answer her directly, not yet, not outside the process that had been set in motion to protect her. The review would speak to her through its own channels. Margaret would make sure she was told, clearly and in writing, that she was not required to support a false statement, that her testimony would be heard in her own voice, in her own time, and that no one would be allowed to use her fear against her. I had to trust that process, even when it felt slow, even when I wanted to move faster. My role was to receive what the review established, not to intervene in it. I kept reminding myself of that, because the temptation to intervene was strong, and the discipline to stay separate was the only thing that would keep the findings clean.

The question that had been with me since the corridor returned then, sharper than before. I had asked it silently, in the first minutes after Miller struck me, when I was still sitting on the floor with my papers around me and the sound of his laugh still in my ears. Would it have been acceptable if I were Maya Reynolds? Would it have been acceptable if the woman he shoved against the wall, the woman he slapped, the woman he laughed at, had been a defendant in dark clothing waiting for her nine o'clock case, instead of a judge in dark clothing walking to her courtroom? I had known the answer then, and I know it now, but the review had sharpened it, had given it a shape I could not look away from. It would not have been acceptable for Maya either. It would not have been acceptable for any woman, for any person, to be stopped on a description alone, to be shoved, to be struck, to be laughed at, to be written into a false statement as a witness to her own intimidation. And the whole morning had been built on making sure no one asked that question. Miller had built it on a buried complaint, on an invented warrant, on a description with no verification, on a statement filed before the video was reviewed, on a name used as pressure. Each step had been designed to make the next step harder to question, to make the people who might have asked the question afraid to ask it, to make Maya afraid to speak, to make the crowd doubt what they had seen, to make me doubt whether the record would hold. The question would not go away. It sat in my chambers with me, and it waited for the review to answer it with findings, not with outrage.

News in the same category

A Police Officer Slapped a Black Woman in the Courthouse, Certain She Was a Criminal—Until a Bailiff Called Her “Your Honor” and Exposed His Secret

45 Part