I remember one morning in particular, though I will not name the people involved, because their names belong to them and not to this hallway. A young man I represented had come to court in his best shirt, the collar pressed, the sleeves a little too short. He had done everything I asked him to do. He had arrived early. He had brought his paperwork in a folder. He had answered every question I put to him with care. And still, when an officer in the hallway asked him where he was going, he froze. He did not freeze because he had done something wrong. He froze because he had been stopped before, in other places, for reasons that were never explained to him, and his body remembered what his mind was trying to forget. I stepped between them then, as Thomas has stepped between Miller and me now, and I said his name, and I said my own name, and I said we were expected in a courtroom upstairs. The officer let us pass. The young man did not speak again until we were inside the courtroom, and when he did, his voice was shaking. "I thought he was going to take me," he said. "I thought I had done something wrong by being here." I told him he had done nothing wrong. I told him the courthouse belonged to him, too. I am not sure he believed me. I am not sure I believed myself, entirely, on that morning. But I have never forgotten the way he held his folder against his chest, as if the papers inside it might protect him.
I remember another client, a woman older than I am now, who had never been inside a courtroom before her own case brought her there. She arrived with a neighbor, because she did not want to come alone, and she sat on a bench with her hands folded in her lap, watching every uniformed person who passed. When a bailiff spoke to her, kindly, to tell her where to wait, she thanked him three times, as if gratitude might keep her safe. Later, she told me that she had spent the night before rehearsing what she would say if someone stopped her. She had practiced saying her name, her address, the reason she was there, over and over, until the words felt steady in her mouth. "I did not want to sound confused," she said. "Confused sounds like guilty." I thought of her then, and I think of her now, because I understand what she meant. In a hallway like this one, confusion is not treated as confusion. It is treated as resistance. A pause is treated as defiance. A question is treated as an argument. And a woman who says, plainly, who she is, can still be told that she is someone else, if the person stopping her has already decided who she must be.
That is what I am thinking about as I look at the crowd. They are not a mob. They are witnesses, in the oldest sense of the word — people who have seen something and who will carry what they have seen out of this building with them, into conversations at work and at home, into the way they think about the courthouse the next time they have to enter it. Some of them will remember the slap. Some of them will remember Thomas stepping forward. Some of them will remember the way Miller reached for his radio. All of them will remember that a judge bled in a hallway, and that the man who struck her first tried to find a way out. I do not know what they will make of it. I know only that they are watching carefully, because they understand, as I do, that what happens in the next few minutes will matter long after the floor is cleaned and the papers are gathered.
Thomas turns back to Miller. His hand is still extended, palm out, not touching Miller, but close enough that Miller cannot mistake the instruction. "Step back, Bradley," he says, more quietly now. "Step back and keep your hands where I can see them."
Thomas turns back to Miller. His hand is still extended, palm out, not touching Miller, but close enough that Miller cannot mistake the instruction. "Step back, Bradley," he says, more quietly now. "Step back and keep your hands where I can see them."