The supervisor arrived a short time later, a woman I recognised from court administration but did not know by name, with a calm manner and a small bag that held the forms she would need. She did not rush toward me. She waited until the officer with the camera had stepped back, and then she came to stand in front of me and asked, in a voice that was both professional and kind, if she might look at my face. I nodded. She did not touch me at first. She looked, carefully, from one side and then the other, noting the colour and the swelling, the way the skin had already begun to darken at the edge of the cheekbone. Then, with gloved hands, she touched very lightly along the jaw, and I felt the pain flare again, sharper this time, as if her fingers had found the place where the force had travelled deepest. I kept my eyes open. I looked past her, toward the windows, toward the rain, and I breathed through it.
"It will bruise," she said, quietly, as if she were speaking only to me. "It is already bruising. I will note the size and the location and the time. I will note that you report pain spreading into the jaw."
"Thank you," I said.
She wrote as she spoke, her handwriting neat and unhurried, and I was grateful that this part of the morning would not be rushed. She asked me when it had happened, and I told her, as precisely as I could, and she asked me if I had lost consciousness, and I said no, and she asked me if I had felt dizzy, and I said no, only the heat and then the ache. She asked if I wanted medical attention beyond this documentation, and I said I would decide after the record was secure, and she did not press me.
While she worked, the witness collection continued around us. I watched it happen in pieces, the way you watch a courtroom fill before a hearing, one person at a time. An officer with a clipboard moved along the wall, stopping before each person who had been present, asking for a name, a telephone number, an address where a statement could be sent. Some people gave their information readily, speaking clearly, spelling their surnames when asked. Others hesitated, not because they did not want to help but because they were unsure what they had seen, whether they had seen enough to be useful, whether their memory of a few seconds in a crowded hallway would matter. The officer was patient with them. He told them that even a partial account mattered, that the fact they had been present mattered, that no one was asking them to decide what was important. He wrote down what they said, and I saw him pause more than once to ask a person to repeat a detail, to make sure he had the spelling right, to make sure the record would be accurate.
A woman in a navy coat, who had been standing near the benches when it happened, gave her name and then stood for a moment with her hands clasped. "I saw his hand," she said at last, her voice low. "I saw it come up. I did not see why. I only saw that it did." The officer wrote that down, word for word. A young man in a suit, an attorney by the look of his briefcase, said he had heard the sound before he had seen anything, and then he had turned and seen the papers in the air. He gave his name and his office number. An older clerk from the fourth floor said she had been coming out of a courtroom with a stack of files when she heard raised voices, and she had stopped where she was. She gave her name without hesitation, and then she looked at me and said, "I am sorry, Your Honor."
I did not ask any of them to tell me their accounts directly. I did not want their words to come to me first, filtered through my own pain and my own sense of what had happened. I wanted their words to go to the record, to the supervisor, to the officers who were collecting them, so that when they were read later they would be their own, not mine. I stood and listened to the murmur of it, the quiet giving of names, the scratch of pens on clipboards, the occasional question and the occasional pause, and I felt the record being built around me, piece by piece, not in a single dramatic gesture but in small, careful acts of attention.
The young man with the cell phone was still there, near the elevators, and I saw an officer speak to him, not to take the phone from him, but to ask for his name as well, and whether he would be willing to share what he had recorded. He nodded, holding the phone a little lower, and the officer wrote it down. I did not know what his camera had caught, whether it had caught the moment itself or only the seconds before and after, whether it had been steady or shaking. I knew only that there had been a camera in the crowd, and that the person holding it had not looked away. In my years as a public defender I had learned to be wary of video, to know how much it could show and how much it could miss, but I had also learned that video, properly preserved and properly understood, could anchor a memory that might otherwise drift.