"Your grandma taught you to hide," Beth said, gentle as snowfall.
"She said the world takes little girls," Wren said, with the recited flatness of a lesson learned young and learned well. "She said not me. Not ours."
She told it out of order, the way a child does, the present braided into the past. The house — my house, the house on Maplecrest I had walked through with a flashlight and a moisture meter eleven months ago — had been hers first and entirely. She described rooms I had painted. She described the kitchen as it was before we gutted it, down to the yellow curtains with the pattern of cherries, and I felt something slide sideways in my chest, because we had found those curtains in a drawer when we moved in and Erin had thrown them away. She knew the third stair that sang. She knew the basement smelled of rain before it rained. She had had a whole childhood in my house, conducted at the volume of a held breath, and I had bought it and moved my daughter into her bedroom.
"When did you live anywhere else, sweetheart?" Beth asked, when the telling slowed.
Wren's face did something complicated. "Grandma got sick in her head," she said. "She put the stove in the — she kept putting things in the fridge that weren't food. The comb. Her purse. A lady came and said Grandma had to go where the nurses were, and I had to go in the wall and be dust until the lady left, but the lady stayed all day." Her fingers worked at the blanket. "Grandma said don't come out no matter what. So I didn't. I heard them take her. I stayed two days. Then I got too thirsty."
She said it the way you'd report weather you'd once stood in. Two days in the wall of an emptying house, eight years old — no, seven then — listening to her grandmother be taken away, obeying the last instruction she'd ever get. After that there were people, a car, a building with a flag, and then the houses.
"The first house had a dog that slept on my feet," she said. "That lady was okay. She cried when I left, but Grandma said crying is how people try to keep you." She frowned at the blanket. "The second house, the man yelled with his whole body. He locked the food room. I could hear the clock in the kitchen all night and it was so loud. So I ran back home."
"How did you get home, Wren?" Holloway asked it from her crouch, so lightly it almost wasn't a question.
"I know the bus that goes past the library. Grandma made me know our address in case. One-one-four Maplecrest. She made me say it in my sleep." A flicker of pride crossed her face, the first uncomplicated thing I'd seen there. "I said it in my sleep and I woke up and I came home. The window in the basement doesn't lock right. Grandma knew. She said it was our secret door. I climbed in and nobody lived here yet, the furniture was still — " she searched for the word, " — covered up. In sheets. Like ghosts. Then the daddy and the mommy and Alice came, and I moved into the wall before the movers finished. Grandma's wall. It still clicked."
I must have made a sound. Beth's eyes came to me over Wren's head — hold it, hold it — and I held it, God help me, I stood in that doorway and held it while this child explained that she had been living inside the walls of my home since before my family had finished moving into it, eating God knows what, sleeping behind my daughter's closet, and that it had been, in her accounting of things, the best arrangement available to her. Home. She'd come home.
"Who else knew you were there, Wren?" Beth asked, and Wren's whole posture changed — the watchfulness slammed back down like a shutter, and I saw the hiding child again, the one from the shaft, calculating sightlines.
"Alice," she said at last, defiant and terrified in the same breath. "Alice is not in trouble. Alice is my friend."
"Alice is not in trouble," Beth said immediately, and said it twice more in different words, and Holloway nodded along like a metronome, until Wren's shoulders came down a quarter inch. "Alice helped you. Helping is not trouble. Can you tell us how she found you?"
It came out slowly, with detours. Alice had heard her first — of course she had; I thought of my daughter that spring pressing her ear to things, to the refrigerator, to my chest to hear my heart, announcing the house had pipes that sang. She'd heard humming through her closet wall. She'd knocked. A voice had knocked back. For days, by Wren's account, they had talked through the wall in whispers after lights-out, two little girls with a wall between them like the world's thinnest country border, and then Alice had found where the panel inside her closet gave, because Alice Keller has never in her life left an unopened thing unopened, and the secret had become bread crusts and juice boxes and a pair of socks with strawberries on them, passed through the gap in the dark.