Peggy's car was at the staff entrance with the engine running, the way she had said. Erin lifted the baby out of the hamper — blankets and all, one hand under her head, the way she had been trained, the way she had done it for a hundred babies who had names — and put her in the car, on the seat, in a nest of blankets Peggy had arranged there. Peggy got in. Erin stood in the rain in her scrubs and watched the taillights go down the service drive and around the corner, and then she went back inside and washed her hands for a very long time, and finished her shift.
In the morning, before she went home, there was a line in the log in her own section of the chart, written in handwriting that was not hers, describing observations she had not made of an infant who had shown no signs of life. Peggy stood at the desk and watched her, and held out a pen, and Erin signed her name under a sentence she did not write.
"I keep coming back to the pen," she said. "Of everything. I keep coming back to the pen. The hamper I can almost — no. No, I can't. But the pen is the part where I cannot tell myself I was carrying something heavy and frightened and it was all moving too fast. The pen was still. I stood still, in full possession of myself, and I signed."
She had told herself, that first year, that she had had no choice. She rehearsed the sentence the way you rehearse a fire drill. Peggy would have destroyed her — that was true, or likely true; Peggy had ended careers for less, had a word for every administrator in the building, could have had Erin struck off and blacklisted before the week was out, a twenty-eight-year-old nurse against the word of a woman who had delivered the hospital board's grandchildren. And Erin had believed, that first night, the story the ward believed: that the father had run, that there was no one to give the baby to, that Peggy, whatever else she was, was the baby's grandmother, and the baby would be safe with family. Those things were the floor she stood on. But floors, she said, are what you stand on so you do not have to look down.
"And underneath the floor?"
"Underneath the floor," Erin said, "was that I wanted my job. And I wanted to be liked by the woman who ran my world. And I was afraid in a way that had very little to do with Hannah and everything to do with me. I have had nine years to get the proportions right, David. I am not going to get them wrong tonight just because it would be easier to hear."
She went on, because there was more, because there is always more; that is the nature of a nine-year silence, it is not one thing kept, it is a thing kept nine years' worth of times.
She had seen Hannah once more. A week after the birth, maybe two, Hannah was discharged, and Erin was not on shift, but she had come in early for the next one and passed her in the main corridor — Hannah walking slowly, the way women walk after, with her coat over her arm and Peggy beside her with a hand at her elbow, steering. Hannah's face was the color of paper. Erin had stepped back against the wall to let them pass, the way staff do, invisible in her uniform, and Hannah's eyes had moved over her without any recognition at all, and Erin understood that she would carry having been forgotten by Hannah Lawson as one of the central facts of her life, and that she deserved to.
Hannah left Ohio within the year. Erin heard it in the break room, in passing, between other news — the Lawson girl's gone out west somewhere, Oregon, somebody said; well, can you blame her. Erin said she stood at the sink with somebody's coffee cup in her hand and thought: it is over, then. It is finished and buried and the woman has gone to build a life, and whatever I did is in the past tense now. She said she can still remember the relief she felt, and that the relief is the thing she has never forgiven, more than the hamper, more than the pen. The relief. Because it meant some part of her had been waiting, all that year, not for a chance to make it right, but for it to please, finally, be over.
"And it wasn't over," I said.
"It was never over. I just stopped being in the room where it was happening."