"I know you are not at home asleep," she said, "because your wife answered the house phone on the first ring and told me you had gone driving, and asked me to tell you to drive slowly." A pause. "Come in, David. I will put coffee on that will offend you, and then I will tell you the news in the right order."
The station at that hour was all fluorescent light and quiet. Holloway met me at the desk herself and took me back to an interview room that had been made, by someone, slightly less like an interview room — a box of tissues, a child's drawing taped crookedly to the wall, left there, I think, by design. She set a folder on the table and a paper cup of coffee in front of me and sat down opposite with the air of a woman laying out tools before a repair.
"The DNA came back an hour ago," she said. "The lab rushed it because I asked them to, and because everybody in that building has a daughter or was one. I am not going to build up to it, David, because building up to it would be cruel. The little girl from the house is your daughter. Yours and Hannah Lawson's. The probability is the kind of number that does not leave room for an argument. Wren is your child."
I had known it since the closet wall. I had known it since a small girl looked up at me out of a dark she had lived in for eight years with my father's mark under her collarbone and called me by a name no one had taught her — but there is a kind of knowing that lives in the body and a kind that has to be said aloud by a woman with a folder in a lit room, and the second kind went through me differently. I put my face in my hands. Holloway let the room be quiet for as long as it needed to be. Then she said, "That is the first thing. The second thing is harder, and I want you to choose whether tonight is the night for it."
"Tell me," I said.
"When we processed the house," she said, "we went through the attic. You know the attic. In the far corner, under insulation that had been disturbed and relaid — recently, by the look of it, within the last few years — there was a metal lockbox. Peggy Lawson's. We have inventoried it, and everything in it is evidence, and it will all come back to you or to Wren in time, through the proper channels. But some of it is yours, David. It was always yours. And I made a judgment call that you should see it tonight, here, with me, rather than in a courtroom for the first time. I may catch hell for the judgment call. I have made it anyway."
She put on gloves. She opened the box on the table between us, and she took out, one at a time, in the order of the inventory, the contents of Peggy Lawson's keeping.
The first thing was my own letters.
I knew my handwriting the way you know your own face in a photograph from long ago — startled by it, and then not startled at all. Envelope after envelope. My name in the corner, Hannah's name in the middle, the address of her mother's house. Evansville postmarks. Then later ones, local ones, from after I came home. Every one of them unopened. Nine years and the glue had never been touched. Peggy had not even destroyed them. She had kept them, tied at one point with string — Erin had seen the string, years before; the string was gone now, cut, probably, by the evidence team — kept them the way you keep a thing you might one day need to prove you had won. I counted them without deciding to count. There were more than forty. I had written more than forty letters to a girl who died believing I had written none, and her mother had filed them in a box in an attic, unopened, like mail for the dead.
"She read none of them," I said.
"She never saw them," Holloway said. "As far as we can establish, Hannah Lawson never knew a single one of these existed."
The second thing was Hannah's hospital bracelet, the plastic kind, gone stiff and yellow. Her name, her date of birth, and a date nine years gone that I did not need to be told. Peggy had kept that too. I do not know why she kept it, and I have stopped trying to construct a Peggy Lawson whose reasons would make sense to me; the box was not a puzzle, it was a hoard. Some people keep evidence of the worst thing they ever did the way other people keep medals. It is the same shelf in the soul, I think. It is just a different war.
The third thing was the bundle of Hannah's letters.