My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

Chapter 23

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"You know because the letters are in a drawer. Were in a drawer."

"I know because you are the man you are," she said, "and a man like you does not fail to write. That is the worst of it, David. I married you. I have had eight years of knowing exactly who you are. I have never once, in eight years, been able to believe the story Peggy told the ward. I knew the kind of man you were before I finished our first conversation, and I married you anyway, with that knowledge sitting in me like a stone in a shoe, and I said nothing. That is the marriage I gave you. I am sorry. I was told not to ask for anything tonight, and I am not asking. But the sorry is a fact and I am putting it on the table with the rest."

The meeting. She told that too, when I asked — because I did ask, somewhere in the small hours: how, of all the men in Ohio, she had come to be standing in a school gymnasium with me. It was Alice's preschool screening, a health fair, paper stars on the wall, Erin in her nurse's polo shirt doing vision checks with a laminated chart. Alice was small and would not sit still. I was the man who got down on the floor at her level and made the eye chart into a game about pirates. Erin said she fell in love with the back of my head before she ever saw my face properly — with a man on his knees on a gym floor, being patient with her daughter. She said she did not know my name until I stood up and introduced myself, and that Keller meant nothing to her, and Lawson was a name she had taught herself not to think in daylight, and so for a while — a few weeks, a first date, a second — she was only a woman who had met a kind man, and she let herself have it.

"And then?" I said.

"And then our honeymoon," she said. "Eight years ago. The lake house your friend lent us. You fell asleep on the dock chair in the afternoon, with your shirt open, and I came out with two glasses of lemonade and stood there looking at you, at the mark under your left collarbone. The crescent. Like a little moon tipped on its side."

I have had that birthmark all my life. My father had it in the same place; it was a family joke, the Keller moon, something my mother used to trace with her finger when I was small. I had never in my life thought of it as evidence of anything.

"The baby had it," Erin said. "Under her left collarbone. I saw it when I wrapped her — a nurse looks at a baby the way you look at a house, David, all the systems, all at once, I could not have missed it if I'd tried. Hannah had said something once, in labor, half out of her head with the pain of it — she'd said the baby's father had a moon on his chest, that the baby would probably have it too, that she'd be able to tell. I don't think I even registered it at the time. But on that dock, eight years ago, with the lemonade going warm in my hands, it all arrived at once. Whose daughter I had carried out of that ward in a laundry hamper. Whose letters I had seen tied with string. Who the boy was who had supposedly run."

"And you said nothing."

"I stood on that dock," she said, "and I did the arithmetic of cowards, which I had gotten very good at by then. If I told you, I would lose you — that was certain, or I believed it was. And the baby was gone, Hannah was gone by then to Oregon, telling would not give anyone back anything; it would only take. That is what I said to myself, on the dock, and every year since, in some form. Every anniversary. Every time you talked about her — and you did talk about her, David, you never hid her from me, you told me about the baby in our first year, sitting in this kitchen, and I held your hand and already knew. I want you to hear that from me and not have to construct it later. I held your hand and I already knew."

I do not know what my face did during any of that. I know that at some point I stood up from the table, and that the standing up seemed to happen at a great distance from me, the way things happen in the first seconds after an accident. Erin did not reach for me. She had promised not to ask for anything and she kept the promise with both hands flat on the table, watching me, letting me go.

"I have to get out of this house for a while," I said.

"I know," she said.

News in the same category

My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

45 Part