My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

Chapter 29

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"She's fine, David. She's not in custody. Let me say that first." Papers shuffling. "She gave a full statement. Detective Holloway was—I'll say this: the detective was not expecting her to walk in, and she was not expecting the statement to be what it was. Erin has been charged with falsifying a medical record. One count. It arises out of the log entry nine years ago. She was processed and released on her own recognizance this afternoon, and she'll be arraigned in two weeks. There's no plea, there's no deal, there's nothing agreed, and I want you to hear me clearly: this is the beginning of a process, not the end of one. Do not let anyone in that house treat it like a verdict. It isn't one."

"Where is she?" I said.

"She's in her car in the lot. She wanted to call you herself but her phone died an hour ago. She's coming home."

She came home. She parked the car crooked in the driveway, which she never did, and she came in through the side door and stood in the kitchen and Alice launched herself off the couch cushions and hit her at full speed, and Erin went down on one knee and held her and held her, and over Alice's shoulder her eyes found mine, and she said, "I walked in and I walked out." And then, quieter, "It's started, David. Whatever it is, it's started."

The letter from the nursing board came on a Tuesday, in an envelope so ordinary that Erin opened it at the mailbox standing in the driveway with her coat still on. I watched her read it twice. Her license was suspended pending the outcome of the case. Not revoked. Suspended. A word with a hinge in it, Carla said, a word that could swing either way, but from where Erin stood in the driveway with the mail in her hand it did not feel like a hinge. It felt like a door.

She had been a nurse for fourteen years. She had held other people's babies in the first minutes of their lives and she had sat with other people's children through fevers and seizures and long chemical nights, and there were families all over Lakewood who asked for her by name. She folded the letter back into its envelope with great precision and put it in the folder with the elastic cord, and that night I found her standing in the laundry room holding one of her scrub tops, the blue one with the small white stars that the kids on her floor liked, holding it the way you hold a photograph of someone who has moved away.

The hospital announced its own review the same week, which was its own kind of weather. A spokesperson said the words ongoing and historical and nine-year-old records, and said them to a camera, and by dinner it was on the local news with a photograph of the hospital I had walked out of nine years ago carrying flowers and a lie I didn't know I was carrying. They were pulling ward logs, staffing records, sign-out sheets. Somewhere in a records room downtown there were boxes with Peggy Lawson's handwriting in them, and other nurses' handwriting, and one line in Erin's. The review would take months. It would find what it found. Erin watched the segment standing up with the remote in her hand and then turned the television off in the middle of the weather, and said, "There were other people on that ward, David. Good people. They're going to have to answer questions because of a thing I did in a hallway when I was twenty-eight years old." She said it the way you read out a sentence you have already served a hundred times in your head.

I want to be honest about those weeks, because there's a version of this story where I'm the steady one, and it isn't true. I was steady the way a fence post is steady. I did my job. I went out on inspections and crawled through other people's attics and wrote down their cracked joists and their knob-and-tube wiring and their slow leaks, and I came home and I was gentle with Alice and careful with Erin and I lay awake at night doing arithmetic I didn't want to do. Erin was charged. Erin might be convicted. Erin might—Carla used words like probation and license and record, and wouldn't use the other word at all, and I heard the other word anyway, in the space where she didn't say it.

Alice asked her questions the way weather arrives, without warning and right through the walls. She asked them at breakfast. "Why doesn't Mommy go to the hospital anymore? Did the hospital get mad?" She asked them in the car. "Why did that lady on the TV say our hospital's name?" And one night, in the bath, suds up to her chin, she asked the one underneath all the others: "Is Mommy in trouble because of Wren?"

I sat down on the closed toilet lid and I told my daughter the truth at the size she could carry it. I'd rehearsed it in the truck, some of it, the way you rehearse any hard sentence, and it still came out slower than I wanted.

News in the same category

My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

45 Part