My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

Chapter 2

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"It's not a closet, it's a legal liability," I said, because there was a panel at the back of it — a rectangle of painted beadboard, maybe three feet by four, set into the wall under the eave — and the panel was loose. I remember that. I want it understood that I remember noticing it, with my inspector's hand flat on it, feeling it give a quarter inch against the frame. Old houses are full of access panels: plumbing chases, cisterns, the little doors carpenters leave for the next man. Behind that one, my flashlight through the gap showed a vertical dark — a shaft, eight or ten inches of black air between the studs and the chimney chase, running from the attic down to God knew where. An old linen shaft, most likely, or a servants' pass-through from when the house had help living up under the roof. Sealed up and forgotten. I made a note in the little book I keep: *Panel, girl's closet, loose — re-fasten, seal.* Girl's closet. We hadn't even decided it was hers yet, and I'd already written it down as hers.

The house had belonged to one family for most of its life, which the estate lawyer told us as if it were a selling point, and for a house man it was. A widow had died in the spring — ninety-one, in a care facility out in Lorain, the lawyer said, in the tone of a man reading a weather report — and the house had stood empty from her going into care until the heirs put it on the market, three years of standing. Three years empty is hard on a house; they go stale and strange, and things settle that shouldn't, and sometimes — I say this to clients, I say it cheerfully — sometimes you get tenants you didn't invite. I walked the attic with my flashlight in my teeth looking for exactly that: raccoon sign, bat guano, a squirrel's pantry. I found dust an inch deep and a child's height marks penciled on the inside of the attic door — a column of them, dated in a careful hand up to a height of about four feet, the last date nineteen years old. A kid grew up in this house once, I thought, and grew out of it, the way kids do. I closed the door on the marks without thinking about them again, and I want that on the record too, because it was the second thing in that house I looked straight at and filed under *nothing*.

Mrs. Abernathy across the street — the same Mrs. Abernathy who taught third grade and lined Alice's class up early — had lived on Marlowe Avenue for forty years and considered herself the street's archive. She brought over a casserole the second week and, with it, the house's whole biography as she kept it: built by a lumber man, sold twice in the twenties, held by one family from the Depression on. "The grandmother raised a grandbaby in that house for a while," she said, conversational, serving herself the story along with the casserole. "Years back. Sweet little thing. You'd see them on the porch. Then you didn't." She shrugged the shrug of a woman for whom other people's chapters close themselves. "Families scatter. The old lady went into the home and that was the end of it. House just sat. Three winters I watched that upstairs window for a pipe burst, I'm not ashamed to say."

I thanked her for the casserole. I did not ask about the grandbaby. A man in my line of work learns not to pull on the threads of other people's houses — it's practically professional ethics; you inspect the structure, not the story — and besides, Alice was pulling Erin toward the yard to see a beetle, and the moment passed the way those moments do, in plain sight, forever.

I never did re-fasten the panel. That's not a confession I enjoy making, but it's the shape of the truth. We moved in the last week of October with a rented truck and Erin's brother's borrowed trailer, and the fall turned into the particular chaos that moving is — boxes in the tub, the good pan lost until Christmas, Alice sleeping on a mattress on our floor for nine days because her bed frame's bolts had gone wherever bolts go. I sealed a crack in the foundation before the first freeze. I rehung the side door so it would latch. I put a new wax ring under the upstairs toilet and felt like a king. The panel in Alice's closet stayed on the list, and the list lived on the refrigerator under a magnet shaped like a strawberry, and the strawberry held it there all winter, and the panel waited.

Houses talk. I tell my clients that. What I didn't tell them, because I hadn't learned it yet, is that sometimes they whisper, and a man can spend eight months calling the whisper his imagination.

The birthmark is a family story, so let me tell it the way it was told to me, which was by my grandmother, at her kitchen table, with a mug of tea going cold because she used her hands when she talked.

News in the same category

My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

45 Part