My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

Chapter 4

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

And some of it fit, is the thing. Some of it fit so well. Alice had never been a lonely child, but she was an only one, and the winter had been long, and the house was big and full of sounds — I want that noted too. The house made sounds I had catalogued and dismissed: the tick of the radiators, the sigh of the chimney chase when the wind came off the lake, a soft knock in the walls some nights that I attributed, confidently, professionally, to water hammer in the old galvanized lines. I told Erin so. I used the term. Water hammer. I said it standing in our bedroom at two in the morning in my underwear, both of us awake, listening to something small and far away that could have been a pipe and could have been a voice, humming, and I said, "Water hammer, hon. Old pipes. It'll outlive us," and I went back to sleep with the ease of a man who has never once been wrong about a house.

Food began to disappear in April. Not much. Never much. The heel of a bread loaf. Two juice boxes from the pantry pack, found nowhere. A banana. The leftover half of a rotisserie chicken that I would have sworn, cross my heart, I had wrapped and put on the second shelf — Erin said I'd eaten it standing at the counter at midnight, which I have done, in my life, more than once, and I accepted the explanation with the gratitude of a man being handed one. Alice's lunchbox came home with the apple eaten and the sandwich untouched, and then the next week the sandwich eaten and the apple untouched, and then a whole week where the lunchbox came home empty in a way that felt, if you attended to it, thorough.

"She doesn't like the crusts," Alice said, watching me unpack it. "I leave them. The walls have mice for the crusts."

"The walls have mice," I agreed, "that's true enough, baby," and I went on with my evening, and I did not attend to it. That is the sentence I have said most often since June, in one form or another, to detectives and to Erin and to myself at three in the morning: I did not attend to it.

In May there was the smell, and I want to be precise about the smell because I was precise about it at the time, in the wrong direction. Alice's room had always carried that faint odor I'd noticed on the first walk-through — dust and old paper, the smell of a shut-up place. By May it had acquired an undertone. Sweetish. Lived-in. Erin noticed it changing the sheets and said the room smelled like a hamster cage that needed cleaning, and we checked, with some comedy at first and then with my full professional apparatus, for a dead mouse in the wall. I am not proud of how thorough I was. I had the access panel in the hall ceiling open. I had a scope — I own a borescope, I scope other people's walls for a living — and I ran it into the cavity beside Alice's closet and found insulation, lath, a desiccated mouse from the Harding administration, and nothing else. I did not scope the shaft behind the closet panel. The panel was on the list. The strawberry magnet held the list. I scoped *around* the one place that mattered with the thoroughness of a man documenting his own alibi.

The scope didn't go there because the shaft was sealed, and sealed meant empty, and empty meant nothing. I had decided it in October with my hand flat on the beadboard. Inspectors have a saying, which my old boss carved into me when I was still carrying lumber: *You don't find what you've already filed.* I had filed the shaft. I had filed the humming as water hammer and the food as my own midnight appetite and the smell as a dead mouse, and Alice as a vivid, age-appropriate seven-year-old with a friend named Wren who lived in the wall and was scared of the dark but only sometimes.

There was a night in the middle of May — I can date it by Erin's schedule, she was between shifts and sleeping badly in the way of people whose work happens in the dark — when the humming woke us both. It was not loud. That was the hell of it. It came through the wall beside our bed, which is the wall our room shares, through two studs and a chimney chase, with Alice's room: a small tune, four or five notes, repeated, with the pauses of someone breathing between repetitions. It was not a melody I knew. It had the shape of a lullaby and the patience of a dripping tap.

"That's not pipes," Erin said, in the dark, not to argue. Just stating a finding, the way she'd state a fever. "David. Pipes don't breathe."

News in the same category

My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

45 Part