My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

Chapter 26

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

They were not in envelopes. They were folded sheets — notebook paper, some of them, and a few on the backs of other things, a grocery list, a leaflet from the clinic — tied with a ribbon that had once been blue. Holloway undid the ribbon with her gloved hands the way you would handle something in a museum, and she said, "These are Hannah's. Written during the pregnancy, near as we can date them. Addressed to the baby. She never sent them anywhere, David. There was nowhere to send them. I think she just — wrote them. And Peggy kept them with everything else. I am going to step out for this part. Take the time it takes."

She left me alone in the room with my dead girl's letters to our daughter.

The handwriting was the one I remembered from the motel room in Evansville, round and hurried, slanting up the page. The first letter was dated in October, when she would have been five months along, and it began: *Dear somebody.* I read it standing up, I don't know why. *Dear somebody. You are the size of a plum this week, the book says, and you have fingernails. I keep thinking about the fingernails. Nobody tells you that you will fall in love with information like that.* She wrote about the room she was fixing. She wrote about names — she had a list; Wren was on the list, third, with a star beside it, and I made a sound in that empty room that I am glad no one was there to hear. She wrote, in the last letter, the one dated two weeks before the birth: *If you are a girl you will have my mother's chin and I hope you will have somebody else's temper. If you take after your father you will have a little moon under your collarbone, and when you are old enough I will tell you what it means, which is that Kellers carry their sky around with them. He writes me every week. Whatever my mother says in this house, your father writes me every week, and I keep his letters under my mattress like a girl in a book, and when you are born I am going to put them all in a box for you, so that if you are ever told otherwise, you will know.*

I read that sentence four times. *He writes me every week.* She believed that — she believed it when she wrote it, and she was wrong already, or becoming wrong; the letters of mine in the other pile had stopped reaching whatever hiding place she kept, or the ones she kept were from the first months, before Peggy closed the road entirely. Sometime between that letter and the ward log, Hannah Lawson's faith in me was dismantled, piece by piece, by silence her mother manufactured and delivered as my nature — and she had gone into that delivery room believing I had stopped writing, and she had come out of it believing her baby was dead, and she had left Ohio within the year believing both, and five years ago a wet road in Oregon had closed over the whole of it, forever, with my daughter alive in a house in Lakewood the entire time.

I do not remember deciding to sit down. I remember the chair. I remember Holloway coming back in, quietly, with more coffee neither of us drank, and I remember saying, "What happens now?" and meaning all of it — Wren, Peggy, the ward, the log, the woman who wheeled the hamper, who was at that moment sitting at my kitchen table with two cups of tea going cold — and Holloway, who is not a woman given to pretending a question is smaller than it is, said: "Now it becomes a case, David. And cases are slow, and they are not the same shape as the truth, and they will not give you back the nine years. I am sorry. That is the honest inventory. The rest of it — the family part — is not mine to tell you. That part is yours."

I drove home through a city that was starting, at the edges, to think about morning. The sky over the lake had gone the color of wet slate. A garbage truck was working our street, unhurried, with its amber light turning, and I sat at the stop sign at the end of our block for a long time with my blinker on, like a man who had forgotten the last turn of his own life.

Wren was my daughter. It was in a folder now, in a lit room, with numbers. Hannah had written her letters and put a star beside her name. My wife had wheeled her out of a hospital in a laundry hamper and then, eight years later, stood with me under a shower of rice at our wedding and begun a marriage on top of the hole where my daughter was supposed to be. All of those things were true at the same time, in the same man, driving the same truck down the same street, and I understood that whatever came next was not going to be a matter of finding out what was true. The truth was found. The rest was going to be a matter of living in a house with it.

News in the same category

My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

45 Part