My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

Chapter 28

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Wren was across the river at the county children's home, where Beth Almeida had placed her the night I pulled her out of my daughter's closet wall, and I drove over every afternoon with Alice and sat in a visiting room with a table scarred by other families' years and watched my two daughters color the same picture from opposite ends. Wren was polite with me. She was careful with me. She answered questions like a girl returning borrowed things. But when we left she stood at the window of that place and watched the car the whole way out of the lot, and Alice always waved until the building was gone, and Wren always waved back, both hands flat against the glass.

On the third morning Erin came downstairs dressed the way she dressed for work, except that she was not going to work. She had her good coat on. She had a folder under her arm, the kind with the elastic cord, and she stood in the kitchen doorway while I was still in my robe with the coffee half made and said, "I've made an appointment with a lawyer. Her name is Carla Nguyen, she's in Cleveland, she does defense work. After I talk to her, I'm going to Detective Holloway and I'm going to tell her all of it, the way I told you. All of it, in order, on the record."

I said, "Erin."

"I know what you're going to say." She set the folder down on the counter and aligned it with the edge, the way she aligned everything when she was frightened. "You're going to say wait. You're going to say we should think. David, I have been waiting nine years. Waiting is the whole disease. Peggy is dead, and Wren is found, and my name is on a line in a hospital log that says a living baby was carried out of a ward in a laundry hamper and signed off as dead. It is going to come out. The only choice I have left in this entire thing is whether it comes out because I carried it there myself or because it gets dragged out of me in front of our daughter. I am not giving them the second one."

She wasn't shaking. That was the thing I kept noticing in those days, that Erin's hands, which had shaken so badly the night she told me, had gone still, as if the truth, once it was out of her body, had taken the tremor with it.

"Do you want me there?" I said.

"I want you here. With Alice. And—" She stopped. "If they keep me, David. If it goes that way. You call Carla. Her card is in the folder. And you tell Alice I went to fix something. Tell her—" She looked toward the stairs, where Alice was asleep with her mouth open and one arm flung over the cat. "Tell her I wasn't taken. Tell her I walked in."

She drove herself. I stood in the driveway in my robe in the cold and watched her back out slowly, the way she always backed out, checking the mirror twice, and I understood that I was watching the bravest thing I had ever seen a person do and that it changed nothing about what she had done, and that both of those were true at once and I was going to have to live in the house with both of them.

Carla Nguyen kept her three days. Three days of Erin driving to Cleveland in the morning and coming home at night wrung out and quiet, building the statement the way you'd build a raft, piece by piece, everything lashed down. I didn't ask what was in it. I already knew what was in it. I had heard it at my own kitchen table at two in the morning with my wife's hands shaking around a mug she never drank from, and hearing it again in a lawyer's office didn't make it any more or any less true.

On the fourth day she went to Holloway.

I stayed home with Alice, who had been kept home from school with a stomach ache that was not in her stomach. We built a fort out of the couch cushions. We watched a movie about penguins. Twice Alice asked me where Mommy was and twice I said, "Mommy had to go talk to some people about something important," and the second time Alice looked at me with the flat, assessing stare that seven-year-olds keep in reserve for adults who are lying by leaving things out, and said, "Is it about Wren?" and I said, "Yes, baby. It's about Wren," and she nodded and went back to the penguins like a small judge who had received the answer she expected.

The phone rang at four. It was Carla, not Erin, and my stomach dropped through the floor before she said a word, because lawyers call when the news needs a frame around it.

News in the same category

My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

45 Part