And still, twice in those weeks, a car door slammed on our street at the wrong hour and Wren was gone from the table before the sound had finished — into the closet, into the shaft, silent, knees up, in the amber light, faster than thought. Both times Alice went to the opening and sat down cross-legged and talked to her in a low, ordinary voice about nothing — about the hamster, about a song from music class — until Wren's breathing slowed and she came out on her own, dusty and furious with herself, and both times Erin, standing in the hallway with her hands twisted together, did not go in, and did not speak, and let the sisters handle it, because she understood before I did that her voice, at that moment, in that doorway, was not yet a comfort Wren could afford.
Beth's first unannounced visit came on a Wednesday at four in the afternoon, which was exactly what the court order said her visits could be: unannounced. I knew that. I had signed the paper. But knowing a thing in a lawyer's office and hearing your own doorbell ring while your eight-year-old is doing long division at your kitchen table are two different countries, and Wren was in the closet shaft before the bell had finished — not scared, not crying, just gone, with the speed of a decision her body had made a thousand times before her mind got a vote. I stood in the kitchen with her pencil still rolling on the table and I felt something rise in me toward Beth, toward the order, toward the whole apparatus, that was as close to hatred as I have ever come at a person doing her job.
Beth saw my face. Beth saw the empty chair. To her lasting credit, she did not call Wren's name, and she did not write anything down, and she said, in a perfectly ordinary voice, "I left my good pen in the car, David. I'm going to go and get it, and I'm going to take my time, because I am forever losing things in that car," and she went out and stood by her sedan in my driveway for a full five minutes, in plain view of the kitchen window, doing nothing at all with her hands empty at her sides.
I went to the closet. Alice was already there, cross-legged at the opening, not talking this time — just sitting, being a sister at the mouth of the wall the way you'd sit with someone at the edge of deep water. "It's Beth," I said, to the amber dark. "Not to take you. To see the house. She has to look at the house sometimes and write that it's a good house. That's her whole job. And she is going to stand in the driveway until you say she can come in, because I am going to go tell her that those are the rules in this house, that nobody walks in on you. Not ever again. Do you hear me?"
A long quiet. Then, small: "She can't come in the closet."
"She will never come in the closet. Nobody comes in the closet but you."
"She can't look at me today."
"Then she won't," I said. "She'll look at me and at the refrigerator and at your math homework, and she'll write that this is a house where a girl does long division, and she'll go. And when you want to meet her standing up, in the kitchen, like a person and not like a visit, you tell me and it'll be that day and not before."
She came out eleven minutes later, dusty at the knees, and she did not meet Beth standing up that day — she watched from the top of the stairs while Beth drank a glass of water in my kitchen and complimented the drawing on the refrigerator and asked me about the school, and when Beth left she said, to no one in particular and to the whole arrangement at once, "She went back outside when I ran. She didn't chase." She said it like a scientist recording the first result of an experiment she intended to run many more times. "Write that part down," she told me. "In case she forgets she did it."