"How long, Wren?" Beth asked. "How long has Alice known?"
"Weeks and weeks," Wren said. "Since the leaves were little." Spring, then. Since spring, my seven-year-old had been feeding a child in her closet wall and keeping it from us with a discipline that grown people fail at, because a frightened girl had begged her: they'll take me away again, and I don't want to go away again, I want to stay home.
I went out into the corridor because I needed the wall against my back to be a different wall. Through the glass I could see Beth getting Wren settled, the broth, the crackers going under the pillow in full view of everyone and everyone pretending not to see, the whole ward performing the fiction that this was a normal night. My phone had charged enough on the nurse's borrowed cable to ring, and it was my sister Carol, with Alice asleep at last on her couch in her clothes.
"She made me promise to ask," Carol said. "She made me write it down. Is the girl in the wall okay, and does she know Alice didn't tell on her. That was the whole message. David — what girl in what wall?" And I stood in a hospital corridor at midnight and told my sister that there had been a child living in my house since before we'd finished moving in, and Carol was quiet a long time and then said, "Alice asked for extra sandwiches all spring. For her lunchbox. I thought she was trading them." Extra sandwiches all spring. My daughter had run a supply line past all of us, in plain sight, in a unicorn lunchbox.
In the morning they would talk to Alice, gently, at Carol's, with Beth and a woman whose whole job was making questions safe for children. Tonight she slept in her clothes on my sister's couch with her shoes lined up by the door, and I tried to be grateful for the order of those shoes.
It was Holloway who took me into the family room, sometime past one in the morning, with two vending-machine coffees and her notebook finally open. The room had a couch upholstered in something that could be hosed down and a box of tissues placed with intent. She didn't start with the girl. She started with the house.
"You bought it last fall," she said. It wasn't a question; she'd already pulled the records. "September. From an estate sale — the owner went into care."
"Margaret Lawson," I said. "She'd gone into a nursing home that summer. The sale went through her attorney. We never met her. She died in January — the realtor sent a note, actually, when her obituary ran, because we'd asked after her at the closing. She'd lived there since the seventies."
"Did you inspect the house yourself, Mr. Keller?"
"David. And no — conflict of interest, I had a colleague do it for the bank. I walked it, though. I walk every house." I heard my own voice doing the thing it did at work, competent, measuring. "I noticed the closet in the back bedroom was shallow. Bedrooms in those twenties houses have deep closets, and that one — the geometry was off by maybe three feet. I remember standing in it thinking the original plans would tell me why, and then we were moving in, and Alice chose that room because the window looks at the maple, and life — " I stopped. "I noticed, Detective. That's my job, noticing houses. I noticed and I painted it and my daughter slept against that wall all year."
"David." She said it once, firmly, not unkindly. "A sealed service shaft behind a closet panel is not something a walkthrough finds. A woman concealed a child in that house for years with intention and practice. That's not a crack in the plaster you missed. I need you to hear that from me now, because I can see you building a scaffold around it, and I don't need you up on a scaffold. I need you here."
I nodded, and drank the coffee, and it was terrible, and I was grateful for something in the world being exactly as bad as advertised.
"Now," she said, and turned a page. "The name Lawson. Margaret Lawson. Does it mean anything to you beyond the sale? Take your time."
I took my time. I took so much time that the IV pump down the hall beeped and was answered and beeped again. Because the name had been working in me all night, under everything else, the way water works under a foundation — and I am a man whose whole trade is foundations, who tells clients every week that what you can't see is what decides whether a house stands. Margaret Lawson. Peggy. A woman I'd met twice, nine and ten years ago, in a kitchen in a house on Maplecrest Street, who had made tea in a pot with a chipped spout and called me "my David" both times like she was trying the words on for size.