My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

Chapter 14

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Peggy," I said. "Her name was Peggy. Her friends called her Peggy. She was — " I had to stop and start again, because the sentence had an end I couldn't yet say out loud in that room. "She was the mother of the woman I was engaged to. Before Erin. Her daughter's name was Hannah. Hannah Lawson."

Holloway wrote it down. Her face did not change at all, which is how I knew it mattered.

It came out of me in the order it had happened, which is not the order it lived in my head. In my head it lived all at once, all the time, in the room behind the room.

I met Hannah Lawson at a cookout in the summer I was twenty-nine, at the house of a guy I inspected roofs with, and she was laughing at something before I'd even reached her, and that was it, that was the whole story of how. She was a bookkeeper for a dental practice. She had her mother's hands and her own opinions about everything, delivered fast and funny, like she was afraid a serious sentence would get away from her. We were engaged inside a year. She moved her plants into my apartment. We had a date — the June after the baby. People say "after the baby" about weddings like weather.

I was working out of state when it happened. A contract job, six weeks inspecting a run of bridges over the Ohio River for a firm out of Cincinnati, the kind of money you don't turn down with a wedding coming. Hannah was thirty-six weeks and furious about the timing and then not furious, making jokes about it, sending me pictures of her feet because she couldn't see them anymore. I talked to her the night before. She said the baby was practicing for a dance career. She said, "Come home Friday and marry me before I change my mind about the whole enterprise." Those were close to her last words to me, and she said them laughing.

The call came at 3 a.m. in a motel outside Covington, and it was Peggy. I need to be precise about this because I was precise about it to Holloway, sitting in that family room with the hoseable couch: it was Peggy who called me. Her voice was destroyed. She said the baby had come early and wrong, she said Hannah had labored for hours, she said the cord — something about the cord — and she said, "The baby didn't live, David. Our girl didn't live." And then she was crying too hard to talk, and a nurse took the phone, a woman's voice I didn't know, very calm, and confirmed it in the calm words. Stillborn. A daughter. I'm so sorry.

I drove four hours in the dark with my hazards on for part of it, like an idiot, like the hazards meant something. When I got to the hospital Hannah wouldn't see me. Peggy met me in the corridor with her coat on over her nightdress — she'd never changed, I remember that, the nightdress under the coat, a woman who'd left the house inside the worst hour of her life and never gone back to fix it — and she held my face in both hands and said Hannah couldn't, not yet, that seeing me would — she said Hannah blamed the empty chair, the job, me not being there, and that grief makes people cruel and to give her time. I gave her time. I gave her so much time. I wrote letters. I drove to Maplecrest and sat in the car. Peggy brought tea out to the car once, in the chipped pot, and told me Hannah had gone to stay with a cousin in Michigan to recover, that she'd written to say she couldn't come back to a life where a baby's room was painted and empty. The room was painted. At my apartment. Yellow, because Hannah said green was a rumor and yellow was a fact. I painted over it myself two years later, gray, four coats, and I could still find it if I scraped.

"Did you ever see documentation?" Holloway asked. "A death certificate. A hospital record. Anything."

"No." I said it and heard how it sounded. "I was told she was cremated. There was — Peggy said there was a service at the hospital chapel, small, before I got there. I believed — " I stopped. "Detective, I believed everything I was told because the people telling me were destroyed by it too. Peggy was destroyed. You don't cross-examine a woman in a nightdress in a hospital corridor. You hold her up. I held her up."

News in the same category

My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

45 Part