My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

Chapter 24

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"If I stay I will say things that are only true in the way a fire is true."

"I know that too," she said. "David. The keys are in the bowl. Drive slowly. That is the only thing I am asking, and I am asking it as a nurse."

I drove. I drove the length of Lakewood and into the city and out of it again, on roads I inspect in my working life, past houses I have crawled under and attics I have stood in with a flashlight in my teeth. I am a home inspector. I have made my living for fifteen years by knowing what is inside walls — the wiring, the rot, the nests, the old repairs, the places where water gets in and travels in the dark and brings a ceiling down years later, three rooms away from the leak. I have told a hundred clients that a house will always tell you the truth if you know how to look. I drove for an hour with both hands on the wheel, thinking about the walls of my own house, and the walls of the house at the center of all of this, and the fact that I had been living my whole life three rooms away from the leak.

I ended up, the way I suppose I was always going to end up, on the street where Hannah and I had lived.

It is not much of a street. It never was. A row of narrow houses with porches, most of them split into doubles, on the east side of the city. We had the upper half of a gray double with a kitchen so small we ate standing up half the time and laughed about it, and a landlord who let us paint the bedroom a green Hannah chose out of a book about the sea. I parked across the street with the engine off and sat looking up at the windows, which were lit, which belonged to strangers. Someone in our old kitchen was washing dishes. I could see the shape of it through the curtain. I sat in my truck and did something I had trained myself out of doing across nine years of being a functioning man: I went through it all, on purpose, in order.

The contract job — fourteen months in Indiana, building inspection work for a firm that paid too well to refuse, when we had nothing, when the plan was that I would bank the money and come home and we would get married in the courthouse with her mother's disapproval hanging over it like weather we intended to outlast. Hannah found out she was pregnant two months after I left. She wrote to me — her letters reached me; it was mine that never reached her, and I did not know that, I knew only that as the months went on her letters changed, cooled, thinned, stopped answering my questions, and then stopped. I read them in a motel room in Evansville until I knew them by heart. I read them as a woman deciding she did not want me. It never once occurred to me that I was reading a woman whose own letters were being answered by silence — because the silence was mine, manufactured for me by her mother, and delivered to her as my character.

I came home to a baby already buried — no. Not buried. That was the refinement of it. I came home to a story with no edges I could hold: a baby who had been stillborn, a cremation I had missed, a girl who would not see me, a mother who stood in a doorway and told me, with something I took for grief and now know was triumph wearing grief's coat, that Hannah had nothing to say to me and that if I had cared I would have been there. I believed her. I want that understood, because Erin is not the only one who closed a drawer quietly. I believed Peggy Lawson, because disbelieving her would have required me to imagine a thing so large that my mind simply declined it, the way a body declines a weight it cannot lift. I grieved a dead daughter and a lost girl for nine years, and some of that grief was real and some of it was a story I had been handed, and sitting in the truck I could no longer tell which parts were which, and that not-knowing was its own country.

My phone rang a little after three. Holloway.

I had given Detective Jane Holloway my number two days earlier, in a hallway, and she had the voice of a woman who does not call at three in the morning with anything that can wait. "Mr. Keller," she said. "I am sorry about the hour. I am sorrier about the reason. Can you come in? There are two things, and I would rather do both of them with you sitting down, in a room, than over a phone in a truck."

"You know I'm in a truck," I said.

News in the same category

My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

45 Part