My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

Chapter 8

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Here," she said. "This is her door. It only opens a little bit, from my side it only opens a little bit, and I push the food through the crack. She can hear you. She's probably listening right now." She bent, suddenly, and put her mouth to the seam of the panel with a tenderness that rearranged something in my chest. "Wren? Wren, it's me. I brought my daddy. He's going to open it properly. Don't be scared. He's the finding-things one."

From behind the panel — and I will have to live with the fact that my first clear thought was *the pipes, the house settling, the wind in the chase*, my mind scrambling for its files even then — from behind the panel there came a sound. Not a knock. Not a hum. A shift. The sound of something that had been holding very still deciding to move, fabric on wood, a small indrawn breath that was not my daughter's and not my wife's and not mine.

Erin's hand closed on my wrist hard enough to hurt.

"David," she said.

"I hear it," I said. My voice sounded to me like it was coming from the bottom of the stairs. "Alice. Go stand with Mommy."

"No," Alice said, with enormous calm. "She'll be scared if I'm not here. She knows my voice."

The pry bar lives in the hall closet with the rest of the tools I keep upstairs for picture-hanging and small repairs. I remember getting it. I remember the ordinary weight of it in my hand, and thinking — and this is the part I have never said aloud to anyone, not even in the afterward — I remember thinking, *Fine. Fine. We'll open it, it'll be insulation and a mouse nest and a dead smell, and Alice will see there's nothing, and that will be the kindest possible end to this. We'll open the wall and close the subject.* I was still, with a pry bar in my hand and my wife's fingers in my wrist, planning to be right.

The panel had been painted shut decades ago and then, at some point, worked at from the other side or worried loose by small hands and time, because it came away easier than a sealed panel should. The paint seam cracked with a sound like a book's spine. The beadboard gave a quarter inch, an inch; a smell rolled out of the gap that I had been smelling for eight months and filing under *dead mouse* and *dust and old paper*, and it was neither. It was the smell of a lived-in place that has never been aired — warm, close, human, unmistakable, the smell of a cot in a barracks, of a room with a person in it. My hands stopped working for a moment on their own. Alice's hand found the hem of my shirt and held it.

"Careful," she whispered. "Her eyes. The light hurts her eyes. Go slow, Daddy."

I went slow. The panel swung on no hinge — it was never meant to be a door from this side — and I lifted it free of the frame and set it down against Alice's dresses, and I took the flashlight Erin had brought without my asking, Erin who had known to bring a flashlight, Erin who had believed enough to arm herself, and I put the beam into the dark.

The shaft was not a shaft. That was the first thing — the thing my inspector's mind registered before my father's mind could stop it. It went down, yes, black and vertical beside the chimney chase, but at the level of Alice's room it had been floored and widened a lifetime ago into a kind of coffin of a space, a servant's cubby or a linen closet that some renovation had swallowed: lath and plaster, a run of old flooring, maybe five feet deep and three wide, running back under the eave into the dark. There was a mattress in it. I use the word the way you'd use it in a report. There was a narrow foam mattress of the kind sold for camping, compressed almost flat, covered with blankets I recognized — a quilt from our own linen closet, the spare one, the one whose absence I had attributed to the move. There was a plastic water bottle, and another. There were food wrappers folded with terrible neatness into a stack, the way a child folds things she believes she must hide. There were drawings taped at crouching height along the plaster, in crayon, at the level where a person sitting on that mattress would see them: horses. A house with its windows lit. A tall man, a woman with her hair up, a girl holding both their hands, and a fourth figure, thin, drawn at the edge of everything, standing in a white space that had no floor.

And there was the girl.

News in the same category

My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

45 Part