My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

Chapter 16

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

She would not go home. Carol offered; I offered; the discharge nurse all but prescribed it. Erin said she was not leaving the hospital while Alice was upset and Wren was upstairs, and since Wren was ours — she stopped herself on the word ours, visibly, like it had tripped her — while Wren was upstairs alone, and so we established a kind of camp in the family waiting room on the pediatric floor, with Carol bringing Alice after lunch and a bag of Erin's clothes and both our phone chargers and a Tupperware of sandwiches no one ate.

It was in that waiting room that I tried to show her the photographs. I want to be fair to myself about why. Holloway had sent me a set of them that morning — documentation, the shaft as the crime-scene techs found it before anything was moved, sent to me because it was my house and I was, in the careful language, a cooperating party. I had looked at them alone in a stairwell: the little mattress, child-sized, on the floor of the shaft. A blanket folded into a pillow. Three paperback books with swollen spines. Drawings crayoned directly onto the studs inside the wall, low down, at the height of a child sitting with her back against the other side of my daughter's bedroom — a house, a tree, a tall figure and a small figure holding hands. And the tin, green, the size of a lunchbox, shut tight, on a strip of carpet laid over the subfloor like a rug in a dollhouse. I had stood in the stairwell and cried in a way that embarrassed me even alone. And then I had thought: Erin needs to see. Erin thinks a stranger wandered into our lives. Erin needs to understand it was a child being careful in the dark, three feet from where Alice slept, and then it will be real to her the way it's real to me, and we can be frightened of the same thing in the same room.

I sat down beside her and opened the first one and turned the phone toward her, and Erin looked at my hand — not the screen, my hand — and said, "No."

"Erin. It's just the space, it's not — there's nothing graphic, it's where she — "

"No." She stood up. She stood up so fast the chair legs shrieked on the tile, and two people across the room looked over, and she lowered her voice and said, with a control that cost her visibly, "I cannot look at those, David. Do not ask me to look at those."

"Okay." I put the phone face-down. "Okay. I'm sorry. I just thought — "

"I know what you thought." Her hands were shaking. She pressed them flat together between her knees like she was holding something shut. "I know exactly what it looks like. I don't need the tour."

I have replayed that sentence nine hundred times since. At the time I heard a woman at the end of herself. I want that noted: at the time, I was kind about it. I made her tea from the machine. I rubbed her back. I told her about the night — Holloway, the swabs, the ninety seconds, Beth arranging Wren's sample so it wouldn't frighten her — and I watched my wife receive each piece of it the way a person receives blows they're trying not to count.

Then I told her the name, because she had a right to all of it, and because I could not carry the arithmetic alone anymore. "Her surname is Lawson," I said. "Wren Lawson. Margaret Lawson — Peggy — the woman we bought the house from. She was her grandmother. And Detective Holloway thinks — we think — Wren may be Hannah's daughter. Hannah's and mine. The baby I was told — " I got it out. "The baby I was told was stillborn."

Erin went white. Not pale — white, the blood going out of her face in real time, like someone had opened a valve. She had paled at the panel, in the hallway at home, before she fell; I had filed that as the shock of the thing itself. But this was different and I knew it was different even as I reached for her arm. The house we'd bought from a dead woman was a fact she'd lived with for a year. The name Lawson had been on our closing documents, on the note from the realtor, on the obituary she'd clipped for the house file. It had never once cost her the color in her face.

"Say that again," she said.

"Hannah's daughter. Possibly. The DNA will — Erin. Erin, look at me. Breathe."

She breathed. She was good at breathing; she teaches it to frightened children for a living. In for four, out for six, her eyes fixed on a point past my shoulder, and her color came back by degrees, and she said, very carefully, "Does the detective know about Hannah? About — all of that?"

News in the same category

My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

45 Part