My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

Chapter 6

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

There were drawings, too. Alice drew constantly that spring — horses, houses, a series of portraits of the footstool dog — and taped them to her wall in a gallery she curated and rehung weekly. In among them, from sometime in May, there began to be a second figure. Alice drew our family often: me tall, Erin with her hair up, herself between us holding both our hands, the house behind with its windows lit. The new drawings had a fourth person standing apart, at the edge of the page, sometimes half behind the drawn house as if the house were in front of her and behind her at once. Thin. Long hair, uncolored, left white. Standing on nothing, because Alice had drawn her at the height of the upstairs windows.

"Who's that, sweetheart?" Erin asked, being casual, being a nurse, being good.

"That's Wren," Alice said. "She has to stand in the wall because that's where her room is. Her room is very small so she stands up in it. She only lies down when she's really tired."

Erin told me about the drawings that night in the kitchen, quietly, over the dishes, and I said the thing I will hear myself saying on my deathbed, I think; I said, "Kids draw weird stuff, Erin. It's May. She'll be at the pool in three weeks and Wren will be forgotten by July."

June came in hot. The lake gave up its cold all at once and the street went green and loud with kids, and the pool at the rec center opened, and Alice learned to hold her breath underwater and came home every day smelling of chlorine and other people's sunscreen. Wren did not fade. That is the thing I cannot stop returning to: Wren did not fade. The pamphlet friends fade when the sun comes out and the real friends multiply — that was the arc I had been promised by every reassuring sentence I had read aloud — and instead Alice went quieter. Not sad. Not withdrawn, exactly; she ate, she laughed, she lost a tooth and negotiated the tooth fairy up to three dollars with a written counteroffer. But she stopped talking about Wren at the table. She stopped taping the drawings up where we'd see them. Twice I found her asleep on the floor of her closet, curled on a nest of blankets she'd dragged in there, with the panel at her back like a headboard, and I carried her to bed both times telling myself it was a fort thing, a seven-year-old thing, a phase.

The second time, she woke up in my arms, heavy and warm, and put her mouth close to my ear, and said, in the clear voice of a child saying the truest thing she knows: "I sleep there so she won't be alone in the dark. She's scared, Daddy. You said the dark is just the room with the lights off, but her room doesn't *have* lights."

I put her in her bed. I tucked the blanket under her chin the way she likes. And I stood in her doorway a long time looking at the closet door, which stood open an inch the way it always did because the latch was on the list too, right under the panel, in my own handwriting.

I did not open it. I went downstairs and poured a glass of water I didn't drink and stood at the kitchen window looking at our yard, and I told myself that in the morning I would call the counselor again, and ask about imagining, and about hunger, and about rooms without lights.

I did call the counselor again, the morning after I found Alice asleep by the panel the second time. I want that noted — not because it absolves anything, but because of what I did with the answer. The counselor was kind and unhurried. She said Alice's teacher reported a bright, social child. She said the friend had a name and a biography and consistent preferences, and that consistency, in a seven-year-old, was the signature of a story being *told* rather than a fact being reported — facts, in her experience, come out of children in pieces, out of order, with the important parts missing, whereas Alice's Wren arrived fully formed and stayed formed. She said that if anything, the vividness was reassuring. She used the word *narrative*. I wrote it down in my little book, under the panel note, where it did not belong: *Wren — narrative, not report. Monitor.*

That Saturday I finally bought the screws for the panel. I want that noted, too. I stood in the hardware store on Detroit Avenue with a box of inch-and-a-quarter wood screws in my hand — the right screws, the ones I'd pictured in October — and I put them in the basket with the furnace filter and the citronella candles, and I drove them home, and the bag sat on the kitchen counter through Saturday's cookout at Erin's father's, and through Sunday's rain, and through a week of inspections in which I crawled other men's crawlspaces and tapped other men's tiles and told two separate buyers, in my professional voice, that a loose access panel is never *just* a loose access panel, that you open it, always, because a house will hide exactly one important thing from you and it will hide it behind the thing you keep meaning to fix.

News in the same category

My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

45 Part